30 day experiment tank: Experiment over, moved to Phyto dosing

OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
New 30 day trial starts today.

Going into this..bleach some acro due to high temps. Cyano and algae outbreak poss from high Po4 and No3.

This round of changes.
1. T5. Set up. Coral +, Blue +, Gies actinic, Gies actinic, Blue +, Coral +
When the purple when in cyano and algae grew bad. Interested what the light does with that.
2. Dosed Flux rx for algae.
3. Dropped Reef roids to 2x’s
4. Pulled the tops

ph 8, alk 8.3, No3 15, Po4 .75, ca 470, mag 1400.

A9BBF4D0-EBC8-4DE0-92FF-90C70B983797.jpeg EE82B50D-2639-4BCB-9D56-1FA5D3481B7E.jpeg A1B9A8B5-6496-4DE9-8B0D-E4487475B8FA.jpeg DC451C52-7DB8-47E6-9ACA-159065583A1F.jpeg 1B4B993C-96C8-47F3-A4F7-263938BD73B6.jpeg 191A718B-0037-4737-AEBE-552A724F91AC.jpeg 2D3D6334-018D-4E49-9EF9-D0EB6EA2793F.jpeg 2229AF6A-0CAF-4DF2-AE4F-6043A5A3D139.jpeg 782F4641-F604-4CC0-B9E8-2E0F718AD93D.jpeg AFE52F2F-05F9-4B26-922A-275A089FBE2E.jpeg 3E1703E1-FBEC-4A48-9F70-8E41B9B6982F.jpeg 0C74C705-2C32-4F6C-9A2C-6B819C4F4AA0.jpeg 0AA478B8-3A0F-4A6B-9F8D-FA2AEC0E781D.jpeg CA3245A1-9FE4-4067-BA42-8241862C3CB5.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Week 2.

Algae mostly gone. Next week I’ll do recommenced water change. Coral isn’t doing good since i had a big temp swing.

1575D5FD-F8DC-41C6-A282-EDA3C14F8DDB.jpeg
30C97917-0708-4CFD-96D0-88A40C219543.jpeg
7E2508BF-4999-4AB0-8F9B-48BCF2495AF4.jpeg
EEB511D8-2725-401D-9187-C5F70064A538.jpeg
A60E576F-BB51-429F-801C-1C4691117349.jpeg
AE44BB1F-343F-48F2-86CE-59E2B8FCB261.jpeg
4956BB5F-7DBA-46EB-AA1A-103178CC2261.jpeg
931F1D5B-1724-410B-8A6A-16FD9B9628A4.jpeg
B1BF73B2-D94D-4BDE-9933-F9EE298DB758.jpeg
131D674F-D93F-46C7-AEA2-530CCE6F3449.jpeg
BFB8BA8F-BCC6-4893-BFDC-1C8796093B3B.jpeg
D04BC27F-8661-4BB5-BFB5-5D9C2070142C.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Week 3

Flux RX and Chemi Clean are done. Water change are done. Did not loose anything to the treatments. I lost a lepto and a acro that were on the way out before. Another acro that has not grow veritical has started to plate.

The tank needs more par, next 30 experiment
13BBFFB7-C0FD-4BD0-9AE0-716DCAF41780.jpeg
F50D7FBC-0023-4DEF-BA56-8DB112B87ECA.jpeg
300F6A0E-4951-4C0A-8330-08A3BCC828CE.jpeg
EE4F46E1-722F-4ED4-9BE8-CC7E37712823.jpeg
B03AC5E6-2F8E-4F02-BF64-777122FD20FE.jpeg
2C31D7B2-AD9B-4746-82AB-1749932C6AF2.jpeg
CF6E752F-C241-4A9B-B803-CF22F860681E.jpeg
DD7C1318-0989-454F-89DE-41CA920CC118.jpeg
00DD615C-9F16-458D-9D89-3B9D0D6BC52E.jpeg
5170D396-7FDA-4334-8F3B-23C0B6DD5807.jpeg
F8B41701-65CB-41F4-B4E3-7EC1804B64E6.jpeg
7D36206E-1B48-4672-A162-94A63E59FBA4.jpeg
will be adding a bar, looking at SB right now.
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Week 4. Last week of this run.

No signs of cyano, few small green film algae spots. No harm from the treatments to any of the corals. Did loose some prior to the treatment from the temp spike and cyano.

There is not much vertical growth, but encrusting is starting to become noticeable

4236BC62-DAEB-48CC-9AB3-2EB726B39D51.jpeg
D6918001-614E-437F-89EE-E6BA5B071C66.jpeg
FEEBDD52-7CB2-4D0F-BA51-5102D837D30B.jpeg
954916F4-4DDB-4332-AFA6-40AB84BACF04.jpeg
4193BEC6-802E-440A-9005-AE16CA7BA1EF.jpeg
47EECDF7-DEF9-41DA-92A4-D983BB6FECE4.jpeg
0E73DCD2-47F0-4F1F-945C-ACCE6DEA1F8E.jpeg
7131BE24-B75B-4872-AB83-954DEF364A82.jpeg
2331C44B-CD02-4E3E-91D4-4F61D0D70B40.jpeg
4EEE7EAF-5776-4ED5-AD6D-40870C79B7B9.jpeg
86989461-0FE6-4489-86B6-6EBBD5F1B6B0.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Last week of this run.

We did a lighting switch, chemiclean and Flux Rx. I think you will be surprised. I‘ll post pix then do side by sides. We 4 really saw a noticeable a growth in encrusting. No cyano and no algae. The light and treatments were all a
DB2B7C57-F98F-4073-AA6C-02214E9008EE.jpeg
0871D3DF-E0D2-429E-8843-EED4CEDB8391.jpeg
244A2A0B-6603-4194-A764-9AFA8817C355.jpeg
1D114091-94AD-4141-B9E2-CFDF8B293939.jpeg
77465FD5-7D63-49F9-AC81-0CF2206DDD3A.jpeg
DC177273-88DE-439B-A077-DD3905C309CD.jpeg
85D192AA-31A2-4867-B906-0B51C881D185.jpeg
D7EA020F-05F7-450B-BD4D-0785E49DE434.jpeg
96CA77B3-A2DF-4EE4-BB9C-682A0AB283BC.jpeg
5D54EBC1-EDC6-48B9-ABEE-A8511E495DFC.jpeg
0E8177AC-EC36-4CB5-9B26-481E5E3594BC.jpeg
win.
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Here is a months growth. It really does not take into account plating/encrusting. That is where it is noticeable. All the photos have been taken with the same iPhone 11 prod and with the regular camera , no adjustments or filter. I don’t know how to use that fancy stuff

The next 30 day experiment is going to be EPIC , stay tuned

Most recent on the left

4E3D567C-C515-4A0D-848D-99FAF1F83F91.png
7B3A5015-F8A1-4471-8D0A-57A10361D5E9.png
0A4EC563-CEC4-4622-9B11-E985CCCE6BD1.png
7181354D-2012-413C-BAAC-1B8BBE2F13AE.png
49D630E8-2D0B-4533-917A-D6D7636A8BA0.png
789CA8A3-C301-429E-8076-8625379CF166.png
2E142797-D51E-470E-91B1-13D6CBE69513.png
0F30A331-9789-4527-81EE-A54B38691FBF.png
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Howdy Y’all.

Back for another 30 day trial run on new thing to see how my tank responds. Excited about this month. I just hung an SB Reef Actinic reef bar to help my 6 bulb T5. I have big hopes for this thing. I am also trying out a homemade DE filter. I will run it once a week in place of carbon and other media except rowaphos. My final trial for this 30 will be AcroPower 2 times a week. 40 Mills for my 180.

Pumped for this 30. We shall see. Here are the pics. Added a few frags. I am thinking of an underwater camera. The encrusting is really what needs to be seen. It it what is really taking off..

3ED04202-6405-45E6-81F4-F70DEA273993.jpeg A058023A-AE5B-493D-A6D5-10F6209B826F.jpeg D5ECD863-D594-42BA-8643-A3C728361AC6.jpeg E1EED24A-7B25-49C8-8B62-D85478D5B2C0.jpeg 0024239A-92E5-4932-A265-27486C336F2D.jpeg 9703DEF3-FAD8-4198-9BA0-AA2728268635.jpeg 8A6943FF-1E5D-4B98-ABC6-E6A6B494AF86.jpeg E742BE10-F069-4FC2-A09D-41EB71E552DE.jpeg 2E234CB3-EA0F-48F8-B1F8-1F27D90FA3F9.jpeg 3B80E2A9-036E-4BA9-B218-60A46029200D.jpeg 3556C7EE-32E8-4F76-8874-46205910773F.jpeg 39C61A0A-76E3-4EF9-AAB4-A8726A0E8AD5.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I started this new 30 day run on Sunday, but I left out a few things due to lack of time.

So, for this 30 day trial run I want to see how my growth, color, and PE will respond to 3 changes.

1. I have added an SB actinic bar to supplement my 6 bulb T5
2. I have pulled all media except Rowaphos and in it’s place I will run a DE filter 1 time a week.
3. I am dosing 40 mil Acropower 2xs a week.

Today I went thru and blew off all my rocks and got deep into the entire sand bed and under what rocks that I could with a turkey baster to clean the sand. I then rand the DE filter for this week. It was clear by 8. The filter was clogged by then. Attacing pics below.

Current #s ph 8, alk 8.6, ca 430, mag 1340, no3 3, Po4 .02., Sg .023 temp 78

8F92376D-059F-418B-968E-D0D599E5242D.jpeg
34E7C648-A016-4F3D-9F8C-71986F1AF2B4.jpeg
3E90BA2F-B851-48D5-8B0C-F5A6C3176560.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
going into week 2,

2 things I noticed. Corals is doing great and boy my phot skills stink.

04486A0E-9CB8-4952-A9A6-FA95F78401EF.jpeg AC99A8D5-726D-48D9-875F-ED8E57BBE848.jpeg 92F87F34-09CB-45E5-BC2A-36FD0CEA0A5B.jpeg 69C617A1-8AFF-4A56-B08E-74656B6636E8.jpeg A0B4B17D-F537-47B5-B5CB-51F3E3245C12.jpeg C17F1EBF-3AB7-4946-A3FF-8D87DDD607D1.jpeg C6210AD9-3296-4931-A40C-1393E13823F2.jpeg 7619821B-05E2-4DFC-B4B4-64F4DC4F0362.jpeg 5BBC99E2-E266-4A1F-9784-400165BFB11F.jpeg 2A3F0AEA-5C31-450D-BCEB-1DB1E1A2207D.jpeg 9981C12E-EAEF-42E7-B55D-6BB7CC5E59AF.jpeg 0E404027-D0C0-4B0E-9C97-B543B42A4CEA.jpeg BF346CDE-3E69-49C5-B409-4C2F2CBA784E.jpeg 20C651AC-004E-4F76-89F9-1EF53174F1FC.jpeg 8EBB715D-C835-41FF-9460-9AEB51C9065B.jpeg A78C95A8-04C5-44BA-B6D0-FE11AC351AFF.jpeg 526439E7-B978-452B-8551-F9B281893039.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Week 3 into this run, noticeable growth in the sps.

I will do side by side and water next week.
F581DD2E-3F08-44E9-B243-C891AD3F03DF.jpeg
E38E0836-FC49-40FF-8923-6B510B3B0CCF.jpeg
5557BF16-4A76-43EC-A09A-F419A9F79B94.jpeg
0B05C48E-2603-42C8-8F3A-700E438BCB8C.jpeg
FF5A5BCF-9D3A-4163-8855-0B2B52B94CBC.jpeg
770E5AA0-9F0C-4F5A-9C10-AAF504019110.jpeg
5F9D1D4F-E8E0-4344-BFC8-57AEDCD15D7E.jpeg
8BD37C13-4938-479A-AB80-74BB537EA84D.jpeg
FBF2BC70-A72F-42D6-ABFE-08617A45138A.jpeg
EB7E1DE5-F66C-4A19-BE08-EC7D9F567308.jpeg
A53A7D7C-640A-4E24-8516-F179197FCBE1.jpeg
30F7FD87-4D74-4CB4-AF49-DD845D189955.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This 4 week trial has ended. I’m a day late, sorry.

This was a 4 week run with a new light and supplement. I had to acclimate the coral so the light is just now at 100%. I had some loss due to getting behind in ALK. I was down to 6.4 before I caught it. The consumption crept up quick so I had to adjust my dosers to get caught up

Next up will be a run with a change in flow.

51BDC449-0D3B-40C1-B6D3-0D4D5080B573.jpeg
EE72DFB8-ABC1-4FE8-9B8B-882CD194C94D.jpeg
92BA30E8-BB42-42E4-B240-1724E82ADF69.jpeg
A74BDDED-348D-4599-8D06-6D9E80AC6443.jpeg
3609EB38-F986-43EB-8FC1-9E52D62F0EDB.jpeg
1CEF9263-682B-4BF7-8665-33F9E6C7084A.jpeg
67D1E96D-F05B-462E-83DA-BE0A3C883510.jpeg
2E27EEED-15F5-4E5E-8885-E44071BF8A61.jpeg
194B5B39-19D7-4C56-BACB-F12A11028E8C.jpeg
6DEC2422-1C0E-4170-9FE4-96C64D0033D9.jpeg
373F981D-46F2-4572-B1AD-2AEAD7C9C423.jpeg
1BF757C7-E319-4FD0-A8C5-EE2A8C49B5F0.jpeg
D2722B2E-6716-41A9-BF5B-FD799A67962F.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Here is side by side. Most recent are on left.

This is actually 3 weeks of growth since my first weeks pics stunk.

0FBA1DF0-4C28-47A7-9BC1-F3ECFB595EF7.png 62DF981C-47BB-4BC3-9337-C4E3658716E2.png 35EB3DEB-5DA9-4241-92A1-5E7B10AF0A34.png F77738A8-1EC4-4A5A-BEF7-974D0FC80638.png 129C6810-DA1A-4D48-B224-89C4E0AE40C1.png 62FE045B-52DB-42A4-A99D-B2DAAD057C99.png 1211EF98-1914-405B-9D48-1AE1D476A0BF.png 06449A2E-C20C-4F54-B077-D7FE473E88CF.png 851251BB-EB97-4CBC-8D62-073CEE587BFA.png 791501BC-E65A-4822-92DE-8E0E2F1E1900.png 97EA256B-0E68-41C0-97DE-177833C58D6F.png
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
There's a lot of info on your thread, and I didn't read it, where are you using the DE filter

I have been trying different things in my tank each 30 days. I have been using the DE as mechanical filtration right in the DT to help nutrient export and keep the water clean/polished this 30.

I stopped all carbon and other media accept Rowaphos. No forms of carbon dosing or things along that line. I went with all mechanical. 2 times a week I would stir the sand while running the DE. I put the intake and return right in the tank. After an hour the water was clear and the cartridge would be full of fish poo and other detris.

My #’s tonight were PH 8.15, ALK 6.4, Po4 .03, No3 5, Ca 420, MG 1320. I was feeding the tank 6 cubes a night for my sweetlips and other guys.
 

JCOLE

Grower of the Small Polyps
View Badges
Joined
Mar 12, 2018
Messages
4,158
Reaction score
11,216
Location
Charlotte, NC
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have been trying different things in my tank each 30 days. I have been using the DE as mechanical filtration right in the DT to help nutrient export and keep the water clean/polished this 30.

I stopped all carbon and other media accept Rowaphos. No forms of carbon dosing or things along that line. I went with all mechanical. 2 times a week I would stir the sand while running the DE. I put the intake and return right in the tank. After an hour the water was clear and the cartridge would be full of fish poo and other detris.

My #’s tonight were PH 8.15, ALK 6.4, Po4 .03, No3 5, Ca 420, MG 1320. I was feeding the tank 6 cubes a night for my sweetlips and other guys.

That's a good idea. Did you notice flow decrease as the filter filled with detritus? If not then this might be a good idea to implement it permanently. Hmmm....got me thinking now.
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
That's a good idea. Did you notice flow decrease as the filter filled with detritus? If not then this might be a good idea to implement it permanently. Hmmm....got me thinking now.

Howdy,

Unfortunately you cannot run my set up permanently. the filter uses diatomaceous earth powder that will get clogged with a short period of time. After that depending on the setup water still may flow but the filter effect will be useless. I just use it to grab all that fish waste and other gunk floating at that moment.

Let me know if you want to know more about DE, its main use really is for water polishing but can help in other applications
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hey all

I got super busy, no real experiment I can speak of, and I am 5 weeks in instead of the usual month. But, wow. Some great growth. Some losses and changes as well.

For those that do not want to read back to the beginning ..Every 30 days I was making changes to see how coral reacted. I did weekly photos for folk to see. I skipped October due to schedule. I am posting current pics and then will do a post of side by side comparisons.

This month I have changed the water once. I had to dose Prazi for flukes, I run my t5 and SB Actinic 7:30 to 8. (Highly recommend the Sb bar). I feed reefbugs and use amino acids.

So here da pics

CA9AE26B-A1B4-427A-B61B-9053CC7CCD4C.jpeg D768B41A-70AE-42DA-9436-364E06F67563.jpeg A3830AA9-53D1-47F4-9930-33E40FBBBB9A.jpeg 3A0F145C-8DAC-4575-A06B-2714C1F88924.jpeg FABA4857-F398-442E-8BE1-ADC1C8D2B60A.jpeg 456612F3-9AAC-4B6C-901E-54593DD4AEF8.jpeg 95253772-D338-412C-B4B9-202A2D96E416.jpeg FE1EA677-6254-4EA9-8FE4-85E6971243DD.jpeg 82A58C13-F567-4436-BE60-A6C9C94C93F8.jpeg 049ABF5E-4665-423D-974A-E034D75093CC.jpeg BB705A4E-CA78-402F-9988-2FB22C2C0DE9.jpeg 0E894235-AA7E-48B8-A0DB-2DC0A16C83E1.jpeg 90B25B19-777B-4A59-8428-7068888402AD.jpeg 28739E76-F5B6-4008-9DFE-4E324C487D84.jpeg
 
OP
OP
Mastiffsrule

Mastiffsrule

Where ever you go, there you are, so be nice 2 you
View Badges
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
33,572
Location
Charlotte
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi,

New on left. I wish I was better photographer. The height is nothing spectacular but plating is great, Color could still be better even with the actinic, I may grab mother geissman actinic and swap it for a coral plus T5.

852ECEB4-7071-4299-940F-C8496DDE9344.png
463B242A-9440-4831-9713-93D809D3AFC7.png
A7DC946C-D099-4579-A003-68CDECCCEC50.png
85BA3A44-CC19-4BD9-B097-EA10BC9547B3.png
9B741BC8-092A-4BCB-9CD4-75309D86BA92.png
02E63B71-7AFF-4FFB-B015-47C4F0F2341B.png
8E3A0161-1F12-4E97-BD05-E056B1644BE0.png
 

Dr. Dendrostein

Marine fish monthly
View Badges
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
9,581
Reaction score
20,801
Location
Fullerton, California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Howdy,

Unfortunately you cannot run my set up permanently. the filter uses diatomaceous earth powder that will get clogged with a short period of time. After that depending on the setup water still may flow but the filter effect will be useless. I just use it to grab all that fish waste and other gunk floating at that moment.

Let me know if you want to know more about DE, its main use really is for water polishing but can help in other applications
I use to run a homemade DE filter, with this(see picture) last 10 days, then recharge. 4.5 x20 inches tall.

Screenshot_20201028-185120.png
 
Back
Top