I personally wouldn't hesitate to mix that wrasse with either of the species you have listed.What is the general consensus on C. punctatus? I saw a nice one and am considering it as an addition to my existing McCosker's and incoming Exquisite Fairy
I haven't personally kept one, but I've kept C. temminckii on 2 different occasions, and C. temminckii is very similar. They were both gentle giants (supermales). Didnt bother anyone or anything, including other fairies.