Regarding DOA's, my feeling is that if I order a specific piece, I'd expect to receive that piece in good shape (that is, a freebie would not be an acceptable substitute). If I was receiving a Battlebox of "selected by Adam" frags, the only way I'd feel let down is if the DOA's were numerous relative to the total contents of the box. In any case I'd expect a vendor to appreciate a detailed report of a DOA and be interested in identifying a preventable cause.