Single Clownfish tank size
- Thread starter Jack1235
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
NonstopSoda
Well-Known Member
they are hardy fish but that does not mean they will be comfortable in the tank after they get to a bigger size. if you do decide to do a 5 gallon just be cautious cause they will out grow of it very quick.
Who cares what some people do that’s an immature response. Not one person here agreed that 5 gallon is ok, it’s because we care about the fishes health and happiness and long life. In a 5 gallon with a new hobbyist it will not live one year.
Have you got the tank? If not get a 5 gallon container and you will see how small it is, then add sand, rock, power heads, filters, heater etc to that container and also minus a coulpe of centimetres from the top of the container, as water does not go all the way to the top, you will see just how little water that is, it really is a tiny bit of water.
TheStrangler
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 20, 2020
- Messages
- 239
- Reaction score
- 212
None of us are in the business of selling aquarium supplies so theres no motivation for us to lie to you. Notice every single person in here has said 10g would be the minimum recommendation. The footprint between a 5 and 10g tank aren't really all that different. If you wanted my personal opinion, I'd say go for a 14g biocube or a similar sized all in one. Fluval has 13.5g tanks as well that I think would work reasonably well. A cat can live its entire life locked in a bathroom, but a house is a better size for it. Maybe it needs to stay in the bathroom sometimes, but you wouldn't keep it in there forever. You are likely going to struggle to maintain a 10g tank, I really wouldn't push it with a 5.
NonstopSoda
Well-Known Member
very true after just rock and sand the water volume will probably be only about 2-3 gallons at most.
NonstopSoda
Well-Known Member
+1 !!! I agree! the fluval 13.5 is a wonderful starter nano tank : )
Amphibious Wallet
Community Member
I don't think OP is actually asking a question, they're just asking for permission and then going ahead with it anyway.
5gal is way too small.
5gal for a Betta is also too small. Betta's are probably the on par with goldfish in the most poorly treated fish in the hobby IMO, people cram those things into bloody soda bottles for insta clout or 1 minute youtube videos.
When everyone in the thread tells you it's too small, but with absolutely no knowledge or experience you decide to go ahead with it anyway, why bother asking?
/rant
5gal is way too small.
5gal for a Betta is also too small. Betta's are probably the on par with goldfish in the most poorly treated fish in the hobby IMO, people cram those things into bloody soda bottles for insta clout or 1 minute youtube videos.
When everyone in the thread tells you it's too small, but with absolutely no knowledge or experience you decide to go ahead with it anyway, why bother asking?
/rant
.
Greissinger goby would be an excellent fish for a 5g.
Yes, this is the case. If the OP were serious about the well-being of the clown, they would listen to the advice given and go with a larger starter tank like an Evo or an IM 15g (even a 10g). I have a pair in a 10g prison (very naughty clowns) for now, hoping to move them into a 25 or so when possible. I don't think 10g is optimal for a pair of regular ocellaris clowns for long term.
gbroadbridge
2500 Club Member
You know that clownfish live in the ocean, yes?
I suppose you could live in a toilet cubicle if you had no choice but would you like it?
Gumbies R Us
Certified Noob
Once you add rock, plus sand into a 5g tank it’s not a true 5g anymore. Depending on the amount of rock and sand in there, that clown is going to be cramped in a tank that small. I like all the others think you should get a 10g tank and skip the 5g. That clown will get too big for the 5g and potentially stress itself out. Below I’m linking some websites that list tank requirements for standard ocellaris clowns, and another similar thread to this one.
www.reef2reef.com
www.ocellarisclownfish.com
Clownfish Care: Finding Nemo...In Your Home
A comprehensive guide for beginner aquarists to prepare for having Clownfish in their aquarium.
m.liveaquaria.com
Clownfish in a 5.5g?
This is probably gonna get a lot of hate, but just because I said that you know I know it’s a questionable question! I had to move my tank into my mom’s home office, so that means I only ever see it if I put a small chair in front of it. It used to be a little 10 gallon in my room, so now I...
www.reef2reef.com
Ocellaris Clownfish Care, Fish Tank Setup, Feeding, Compatibility
Caring for your Ocellaris Clownfish need not be difficult. With proper setup and maintenance, your clownfish tank can be an enjoyable, relaxing hobby.
LadyMac
Freshwater sage fish whisperer
Having a million and one bettas, as well as clowns I can kinda see the comparison? Except that in my experience my clownfish are always out in the open, unless they’re sleeping in their barnacles. They are aggressive like a betta can be but usually clowns can be kept with other fish, whereas it’s not really a good recommendation for betta fish. Both species are hardy but they must have their needs met. I house my fancy bettas in 3 gallon well planted tanks because it’s suitable to their needs. Hides, plants, slow gentle filtration and either tannins or dim lighting.
Clownfish being much more mobile, I wouldn’t dream of either of my two (and if you think about how clownfish sexing goes, a single will most likely turn female, and in turn get some girth to her) in five gallons. I’d go moreso for an eight gallon cube or ten gallon standard. It’s not only about the mobility but also the water quality. Bettas are forgiving in the sense that a well planted tank can help keep the ammonia nitrites and nitrates stable. In a saltwater environment, unless you’re using macro algaes you’re not getting that benefit so much.
Definitely would be a good “breakout into the hobby” starter, as bettas are considered but you still have to have their needs met.
Clownfish being much more mobile, I wouldn’t dream of either of my two (and if you think about how clownfish sexing goes, a single will most likely turn female, and in turn get some girth to her) in five gallons. I’d go moreso for an eight gallon cube or ten gallon standard. It’s not only about the mobility but also the water quality. Bettas are forgiving in the sense that a well planted tank can help keep the ammonia nitrites and nitrates stable. In a saltwater environment, unless you’re using macro algaes you’re not getting that benefit so much.
Definitely would be a good “breakout into the hobby” starter, as bettas are considered but you still have to have their needs met.
Last edited:
stewy14
2500 Club Member
can I add in this too: https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/pico-reef.1059285/
this is very inhumane, everyone has told him, and he isn't changing anything
look how bored the clown is in that tank...
its inhumane as heck
this is very inhumane, everyone has told him, and he isn't changing anything
look how bored the clown is in that tank...
its inhumane as heck
dan’s tanks
New Member
Kinda depends on the amount of free swimming space. A 5g filled with rocks is a lot different than one with a more minimalistic scape. That being said, there are so many more interesting (my opinion) fish that are better suited towards life in a smaller aquarium (think small gobies and blennies. My clowns are pretty social, and use up my entire tank for space, so I would feel a bit bad putting one in a 5g.
stewy14
2500 Club Member
- Status
Similar threads
