New scape! Which is better!?

[LandenB]

Hey guys I just redid my rock work and tried to make things more open in my 30g jbj. Not sure which one I like better tho. Please advise! Thanks!

Old

New

 

[Chrisfish]

I have the JBJ 30 gal. As well and getting ready to open up some space. IMO I like the second one.

 

[LandenB]

I have the JBJ 30 gal. As well and getting ready to open up some space. IMO I like the second one.

Nice! Thanks for your response. It does have more space for coral!

 

[seastar]

New scape! Great work that looks fantastic. It makes you happy right?

 

[Chris Adams]

I think the second scape is nice.

 

[LandenB]

New scape! Great work that looks fantastic. It makes you happy right?

Yeah, my sister is art major and did say she didn't say she liked it (or that she didn't like it). I guess I just wanted positive feedback. I suffer from scape insecurity. Thanks!

I think the second scape is nice.

good deal! thanks

 

[jwhann6]

I actually love both, but if it were my tank I'd pick the second one!

 

[saltyfilmfolks]

I like them both

 

[BruceWayne]

the new one looks very nice great work

 

[cracker]

The 2nd is pleasing to me

 

[ReeferMaddness843]

I have to agree on the second one. I like the island idea and want an island scape myself. Just not the work required to make an island scape in my 90 after being setup this long. . Lol.

 

[LandenB]

Well... I changed my scape again lol I can't be trusted

 

[becks]

Th second was is best

 

[Wilsoni]

I agree on the second being the best. The negative space looks much better

 

[LandenB]

Yeah I did like the contrast of that one but it blocked the view of corals...

Best of both worlds?

 

[LDH]

I vote #2!

 

[LandenB]

This is the one I'm keeping ... hell to the naysayers! Of course... I did ask :/