Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I never said they pull out more organics but pulling them out as quick as possible is just as good right??I'm all for a high powered skimmer. I belive a good skimmer is a big part to success. However, bigger skimmers do not pull out more organics, they just pull them out faster.
If you have a skimmer rated for your tank, it will operate 100% of the time. Getting a skimmer rated for twice your tank will not pull out twice the organics, it will just operate 50% of the time. Talk to most skimmer makers and they will say twice as big is about as much as a model will span. Getting one bigger than that at it will actually pull out less and perform worse than the one that is sized right for your system.
Now whether your skimmer is accurately rated.... well that a whole other discussion. I really like SWC skimmers and the 160 cone, but it will not do a 150g tank.
So why the bigger skimmer if it doesnt matter at the end of the day? Ok I think I read all this skimmer jibber jabber already.I like a bigger skimmer and think they are more affective and you dont but you kinda do and thats your opinion and that is mine goodnight.:tongue:I think I went through the same kinda thing when I was going from metal hallide to t5ho.....but thats a whole different storyWell sure, and I like some head room too. I have a K2 on a 90g. I think it will comfortably do 150g, but some say 180g. If something dies in my tank, I want the capacity to take it.
But at the end of the day, if your system produced 4 oz. of organics, there really is no difference between a skimmer that took that out in 18 hrs or 12 hrs or 6 hrs. The one that took it out in 6 hours is just sitting idle for 18 hrs a day. Mine sits idle half the time.
+1 on the hijack sorry sonny,I hear where your coming from Powerman and thanks for the additional info.I just agreed with sunny on a few of his tips that I myself find to be true.An oversized skimmer will take more room, cost more, use more energy, and worse, perform worse. A seriously oversized skimmer sits all day long waiting for enough organics to accumulate so it can push then up in the huge neck and puke a bit in the cup. Then it waits for more hours. A 160 on a 50g is not grossly oversized.
But I don't mean to hijack. Lots of variety in this hobby. Sunny laid out a good recipe for success and a big well performing skimmer is certainly part of it. We just obviously have different opinions on "how big".
So Sunny, how do you go about planning coral placement. I mean on mine I try to place them all in good spots, but when I see grown out tanks they are just jam packed. Seems eventually they are all going to be crowded.
Hello i just got done with building my 75g sps dom tank. im running a vertex IN-80 skimmer active carbon, i have 2 250w phoenix 14k DE. i didn't know about the power head in sump idea im going to have to do that asap. my cal is 380 but im working on raising it into the 400-450 range. how often should i test my alk? it was 9 on the dkh scale last time i checked which was 5 days ago i plan on dosing vodka after i get my cal, mag and alk in line. any advice??
If you plan on dosing Vodka I would not go over 9 DKH. Anything above 9 usually stress corals out when dosing vodka. Also keep in mind that by compensating for the low calcium your ALK will also be affected.