Hello soon-to-be fellow Reefers!
I've been a long-time lurker of R2R, and after getting cold feet on starting a tank a few years ago, I've decided to revisit that decision with a dive straight into the deep end. I'm going big, and going slow, and would love advice from some of the more experienced reefers than I (which is likely everyone). I'm calling this the "Noob Lagoon" since I've never had a tank before. If I've listed a component with any degree of specificity, I probably already bought it!
I'd appreciate contributions from anyone with cautionary tales, encouragement, alternative strategies, identification of holes and/or overkill, etc... I've "soaked up" details from beginner reefing guides, ULM tank trials, 52-weeks of reefing, etc... on and off over the past few years, so I'm not looking for any more general getting started references, but very much interested in specific guides to certain aspects that anyone thinks would be helpful, or if it looks like I'm showing some weakness in my understanding of that area.
My Goals:
I want a living-room centerpiece tank, with a focus on the weird creatures. (The more "alien-like" the environment (colors/shape/movement), the better!)
My Plans:
Display
Sump
Mixing Station
Automation/Monitoring
The tank is due Jan/Feb of '23, so I have plenty of time to think and plan. I'm looking forward to posting some updates and getting feedback on the things I will likely start up earlier, like the mixing station, QT tanks, sump design and any high-level plans for automation!
Thanks for reading! and thanks in advance for constructive commentary!!
-Sticky
I've been a long-time lurker of R2R, and after getting cold feet on starting a tank a few years ago, I've decided to revisit that decision with a dive straight into the deep end. I'm going big, and going slow, and would love advice from some of the more experienced reefers than I (which is likely everyone). I'm calling this the "Noob Lagoon" since I've never had a tank before. If I've listed a component with any degree of specificity, I probably already bought it!
I'd appreciate contributions from anyone with cautionary tales, encouragement, alternative strategies, identification of holes and/or overkill, etc... I've "soaked up" details from beginner reefing guides, ULM tank trials, 52-weeks of reefing, etc... on and off over the past few years, so I'm not looking for any more general getting started references, but very much interested in specific guides to certain aspects that anyone thinks would be helpful, or if it looks like I'm showing some weakness in my understanding of that area.
My Goals:
I want a living-room centerpiece tank, with a focus on the weird creatures. (The more "alien-like" the environment (colors/shape/movement), the better!)
- Softies/LPS primarily, because I like the movement and color variety, and don't (yet) want to deal with the more challenges that seem to be required with SPS. I'll probably dip my toes into a few SPS though, it seems inevitable, so I want this tank to be able to support a small amount.
- I'm not focusing too heavily on the fish, quantity-wise, or from the perspective of uniqueness. I have no specific fish in mind that is a "must have".
- Low Maintenance, plenty of automation. I'm failure paranoid, so I want to build in redundancy and monitoring where it makes the most sense without unnecessary over-complications. I have a tendency to over-complicate things, so I very much welcome any sanity checks on that!
- Auto Water Changes (Mixing Station in the basement, Tank across the house and upstairs)
- Auto Top-Off
- Eventually auto-feeders for vacation and such.
- Willing to pay for convenience/maintenance reduction/and safety/monitoring (For my pets, and my floors!).
My Plans:
Display
- Tank & Stand: IM EXT 112 Lagoon (36" x 36" x 20") (Bean-animal style overflow)
- Aquascape/Habitat: ~3" Sand & Reefsaver dryrock (Would love aqua-scaping inspiriation/suggestions)
- Powerheads: 2x MP40s
- Lights: Neptune SKY (Hoping I can get away with just this w/o having to supplement)
- Location: Upstairs living room. Smack dab atop an I-beam, ontop of a support pole for said I-beam, so I think I'll be fairly safe, but will post the details so someone can scare me otherwise South facing room, and will get a hair of direct sunlight in winter, but its as deep in the room as it can be.
- Infrastructure:
- I'll need to cut some holes for water tubing, but thankfully that I-beam under the tank means there's a nice channel for running all the way across the house to the mixing station that won't require much complication to set up.
- Electrical wise, I don't yet know if I'm comfortable with the circuitry available. I've got one outlet nearby that shares a circuit with the overhead can lights in the living room and kitchen (not all LEDs yet), and another outlet that I haven't yet figured out which circuit it's on. I'm considering having an electrician hook me up with a dedicated circuit (or two?) for the tank.
Sump
- Sump: TBD
- Mechanical Filtration:
- Socks
- If socks become a PITA, would like to consider a rollermat, but not shooting for that from the start. I figure "Low-Maintenance" socks could be to have extras on hand, swap the dirties into a sealed container in the sump, and batch clean eventually when I'm running low (Saltwater Mixing Time). Utility sink is in basement, I know I'm not going to want to run down there to clean socks frequently.
- No Skimmer (Desire, need to do more research to see how practical it is.)
- Reason for avoidance would be the frequent recurring maintenance, and they seem to be something that go wrong (bubble over, leak, etc..) quite a bit.)
- Socks
- Biological Filtration: Refugium of some kind. Sucking out excess Nutrients w/ Macroalgea is appealing to me, especially if I can "tune" its growth via lighting. The frequent maintenance being plucking some out and throwing it away doesn't seem intrusive enough to me to be a concern.
- Heating: TBD (Desire redundancy/failure tolerance)
- Cooling: None
- Return Pumps: TBD (Desire redundancy/failure tolerance)
- Manifold: TBD All the sexy sumps seem to have one, seems to be a good way to plan to expand. On the other hand, its more complexity in the plumbing, more points of failure, etc... Still considering fully what this enables and whether or not I want it.
Mixing Station
- RO/DI: Old system a co-worker gifted me, need to do more research to see if it'll be sufficient and/or what I need to add to it. I know I've got chloromine instead of chlorine to filter out, unknown what my current water pressure is to know if I need a booster pump, but I hear some of those auto-flush the RO/DI Membranes, so that sounds like a desirable thing to do to eliminate some regular maintenance maybe?
- Storage: 2x 50g Rectangular Plastic containers, 5" fill port, 3/4" drain. RO/DI will gravity feed into Salt Tank
- Heat/Circulation: TBD (With a gravity feed from RO/DI -> SaltTank, and a dosing system from Salt Tank to Pump? I don't think I need any external PVC circulation that seems so common in other Mixing station designs? Is dropping a power-head and heater through the 5" top port at mixing time good enough? or will I want to strongly consider circulating out the drain valve and back in the fill port just for the purposes of mixing?
- AWC fluid transport: Leaning towards daily removal/refill via dosing pump.
- ATO fluid transport: Manual for beginning, but desire automating it. Undecided between on dosing pump or direct from pressurized RO line.
- Location: Basement concrete next to floor drain and laundry basin. Not too concerned about leaks.
- Not too much thought into this yet, but I'm thinking 20-30g tanks with HOB filters, heater, placed next to the mixing station.
- Q: Are any medicines severe enough to permanently "claim" a tank? i.e. I figure two will allow me to observe frags and fish, frags and inverts, fish and inverts, etc... without much concern over treating one killing the other so long as I clean thoroughly between species swaps? Still very much in the research aspect of this, but learned enough to know that quarantining fits my style.
Automation/Monitoring
- Automatic Water Changes via dosing pumps (Frequency undetermined)
- Automatic Top Off (Looking for suggestions here. If I'm doing AWC to the tank with RO line and dosing pumps, seems like topping off w/ the same style might be easiest?)
- Leak detection on/around display/Sump (Design TBD, but recently heard of "leak rope" which sounds promising if it works well?)
- Temp/Salinity/Nutrient Monitoring (I love watching numbers on graphs, even if they're constant)
- Auto-fill of RO/DI Storage in mixing station. (Manual Salt Mixing)
- Salinity monitoring of Salt Storage? (Unless dirt cheap, there's probably better ways like redundant valves to mitigate leaks from fresh to salt screwing up the Saltwater used for AWCs?)
- Probably going to get an Apex (cause toys), but I'm not opposed to handling these with discrete systems either.
- Fish:
- Pair of Clowns (I think its illegal to have a tank without them )
- Yellow Tang
- Sand Sifting Goby
- TBD Others
- Desired, but not convinced its practical so probably not going to get any: Engineer Goby
- Coral:
- Softy/LPS, no specific must-haves in mind.
- Pulsing Xenia is on the want-list, since I love the movement, but it seems like this is more of a weed so unless I can be convinced its manageable, I might skip.
- Inverts:
- Crabs/Hermits/Shrimp/Starfish, I gotta catch 'em all.
The tank is due Jan/Feb of '23, so I have plenty of time to think and plan. I'm looking forward to posting some updates and getting feedback on the things I will likely start up earlier, like the mixing station, QT tanks, sump design and any high-level plans for automation!
Thanks for reading! and thanks in advance for constructive commentary!!
-Sticky