Coral "Names"... Where did they start?

[stunreefer]

Naming corals other than what they are (Genus species) has generally drove me nuts. Don't get me wrong, I can fully appreciate the fact that a morph name can help differentiate between an orange Zoanthid with a green mouth and an orange Zoanthid with a purple mouth, so I do believe it has it's place in our hobby. However hyping corals and triple checking lineage will always be beyond me... does it look awesome or not? Past that, shenanigans

I started in this hobby, and quickly stepped foot into the industry, in 2003. Back then coral naming had just begun, and since then we see threads pop up nearly weekly regarding this topic, who started it, and what does it mean. In my early years we mostly called corals by their colors, literally "Do you have the orange Zoanthid with a green mouth?" as opposed to "Do you have Santas Reindeers Toxic Double Chin Zoas?". "Limited Edition Tyree" corals were some of the first to come with non-descriptive names. Recently Steve Tyree shed some light on the beginning of this trend, which I shared here. The fact that Tyree never called his corals, "Tyree", really made me

Here's the blog post copied into this thread:

Today Steve Tyree shared with the Facebook world the origin of the Purple Monster, Tyree L.E. and coral names as we know it. I especially like hearing Steve’s take on coral names… direct from Steve! If you know me, naming corals has always been somewhat of a peeve of mine. But it is part of the hobby that’s here to stay, and it obviously helps identify a particular morph of a specific species. Without further ado, a little history lesson from Mr. Tyree:


“Hello Reefers,

And I mean the coral reefers, not the… well you know what. Thought I would do a little write up and explain how the Purple Monster coral came into the captive coral reef market. And also how the whole Limited Edition exotic naming of corals began. Saw someone was reading and commenting on my old Dynamic Ecomorphology Purple Monster page. That page has not even been updated in 10 years. Was taking care of 8 web sites for awhile and that number is down to just 5 now. So yeah, the old DE web site is still up there, but way out of date. Also the current Reeffarmers page is out of date. Will get to it when I get some time.

Back when the PM was imported, 1995 from the Solomon Islands, the keeping of Acropora within the US was just beginning. The very first Acropora colony sold in a store was in my reef tank at the time and had grown in captivity to about 2 feet x 1 3/4 feet x 1 1/2 feet in size. Acquired it around June 1992. So we were three years into keeping Acropora in the US. And yes most were not very colorful. We did experiment with the colorful Loripes from Fiji in 1993 and 1994 but were running into KH issues and the first KH crashes. So there was not a whole lot of color beyond brown and green.

Me and three other aquarists in the Laguna Hills area, decided to try to buy a box of Solomons Transhipped Acropora through Aquatic Depot. Getting in Acropora from anywhere but Indonesia was still rare. And the initial Fiji Loripes colonies were very colorful but proved difficult for the captive market at the time. You could not even buy a calcium reactor back then in the US. In fact I beta tested the second Calcium Reactor unit even made for distribution in the US (MKR-1). When I picked up that tranship order, the Aquatic Depot workers were very excited. They said it was the best box of corals they had ever seen. There were 4 very medium to large PM colonies in the box.

Only one of those colonies survived past the first week. The largest one of the box which I had placed in my tank. The colonies had been roughed up fairly bad in shipping. Eventually the Purple Monster began to show its first growth. I did not call it the Purple Monster (PM) and initially did not like the name. But it was what everyone else called it, so the name stuck. There was no way in the world I was going to frag the coral for anyone at the time. Fragging Acropora was still kind of unheard of and no one really had a clue how to do it properly with good success.

A few months later I got hooked up with a major coral importer and for awhile was the number one Acropora transhipper in the country. Stores were buying colonies direct from me. Then it all fell apart as things tend to do over time. The first coral disease hit the captive market called RTN. And this was a very virulent strain of RTN. At the time we figured we did not even have to worry about diseases, pests or predators. Heck we were just learning how to keep them alive and growing. The RTN problem was so bad that it was affecting the entire industry, which afterwards became a shell of itself for a year or two.

Unfortunately I could not tell people about the RTN problem publicly. Was actually threatened with a law suit if I ever spoke about the disease in public. This was around 1996. Dynamic Ecomorphology eventually failed and I thought the failure at the time was primarily due to the RTN problem. Little did I know at that time that a few of the industry insiders were telling everyone that RTN came from my facility only. It actually came from Fiji. So yes, my first company Dynamic Ecomorphology went down in flames because of those issues. Now that I look back at that whole fiasco, Dynamic Ecomorphology was more or less sacrificed for the hobby. Eventually Fiji worked out their issues and people began keeping Acropora again.

And eventually people figured out that my facility was not the only source of the problem, since people who had not bought through me also got RTN. I however was struggling badly due to the failure of DE. Hooked up with James Bond* who owned a LFS in Rancho Cucamonga. And he talked me into fragging the PM to raise money. The older established captive colonies had proven themselves healthy enough to fight off the RTN infection. Bond, James Bond* told me to sell frags for $50 each. Thought he was nuts. Who was going to pay $50 for an Acro frag ? At the time you could buy a small colony for $40 to $50 retail.

Eventually financial pressures and James Bond* convinced me to give it a go. Listed PM frags for $50 to my email list and people started buying them. James was right. So the whole Limited Edition craze began. And it was crazy back then. When I listed a new LE coral, my phone would ring non stop for 2 to 3 hours. People would get mad at me if they did not get a timely reservation. Very weird situation. But the good news was that a market for captive SPS coral frags existed and was born.

Over the years I have come to realize that what people wanted was a product they could grow themselves and sell with a good marketing name. It ended up being a consumer driven phenomenon. And just look at what the consumers have created today. Granted some of it is now out of hand, but its birth was not meant to be out of hand. And unfortunately as everything eventually falls apart over time, we had numerous other issues to deal with as time went by. Acro eating flatworms, Y2K, 911, Red Bugs, 2008 Economic crash and the latest problem, Acro eating sea spiders. Will post a write up about those, later in the week.

To sum it up in a nut shell, the Purple Monster was the first $50 a frag captive coral. And it made me think that captive grown was the best way to go. The image in this post shows the PM on the left and my main display reef a few months prior to the arrival of RTN. Might post some additional images to this thread later.

Steve Tyree“

… And this comment from Steve below the above post literally had me laughing out loud, “And please note, I have never called my corals Tyree corals. Not once. Not ever. Everyone else did. You guys keep blaming me for things I did not do Lol.“

Thank you again for sharing Steve, and we look forward to more hobby history lessons.

*Names of people and stores were changed in Steve’s quote per his request. Steve did not actually team up with 007 to frag an Acropora loripes, although that would be epic.

 

[-Logzor]

Sometimes frags are too small to determine if they are the correct lineage so this is why lineage is important. Some of the more unique corals don't develop their full color or growth pattern until they are the larger colonies. Without lineage it's otherwise very easy to scam people. In my mind this makes good sense, especially if you're paying $100+ for a small fragment. I wan't to have some degree of confidence it's the right coral.

 

[stunreefer]

Sometimes frags are too small to determine if they are the correct lineage so this is why lineage is important. Some of the more unique corals don't develop their full color or growth pattern until they are the larger colonies. Without lineage it's otherwise very easy to scam people. In my mind this makes good sense, especially if you're paying $100+ for a small fragment. I wan't to have some degree of confidence it's the right coral.

I agree - if lineage of a coral is what you're after. I know many people are, and I can certainly see the appeal. We see this type of thing in many facets of life, whether it's lineage of horses or dogs, car collections, etc.

And don't get me wrong, I have named corals! One of my favorite's is the "Space Invaders" Pectinia. One could simply call it a green Pectinia with yellow mouth/eye/manus. However I've personally seen at least a half dozen Pectinia color morphs that are green bases with yellow mouth/eye/manus. None of them could hold a candle to the infamous "Space Invaders" as the green was more muted, or forest green, or it had more orangish mouth/eye/manus, etc.

I added my $0.02 at the top of the O.P., but no one cares about that, heck I don't care about my $0.02 However I was intrigued to read of Steve's take on where it all started from, and how other people were the one's to start labeling his corals as "Tyree corals". He shared another story recently recalling a frag swap in the early days where someone came over and said, "Do you have any Tyree corals?" not knowing whom he was. Another person that owns a store commented they had a customer come in and ask about a coral, then ask, "Is that a Tyree coral?". Then ask, "Is Tyree a person or something?"

 

[buddythelion]

Articles about the history of corals are always my favorite! This was a really rare treat for me to read, and definitely will remember it.

For some reason, I thought purple people eaters were the first named corals. Guess I was wrong, or maybe they were the first named zoanthids?

 

[FX CharityCorals]

That was fantastic to read. Thank you Stun for posting that and thank you Steve for being a true pioneer.

 

[stunreefer]

Articles about the history of corals are always my favorite! This was a really rare treat for me to read, and definitely will remember it.

That was fantastic to read. Thank you Stun for posting that and thank you Steve for being a true pioneer.

:thumb:

For some reason, I thought purple people eaters were the first named corals. Guess I was wrong, or maybe they were the first named zoanthids?

You've got me there! I know they've been around for as long as I can remember

 

[kdino1]

Great read. very interesting to read about the roots of the industry/hobby.

 

[Ike]

"The very first Acropora colony sold in a store was in my reef tank at the time and had grown in captivity to about 2 feet x 1 3/4 feet x 1 1/2 feet in size. Acquired it around June 1992"

I found the part above a little comical... I had seen Acropora in wholesalers tanks as far back as 1990, and I'm quite certain they were being imported well before that. Maybe I'm wrong, but I can recall Acropora being available from a few of the higher end fish stores as early as 1986. I had what I believed to be an A. samoensis colony that I received in the summer of 1991 from International Seaboard in Chicago that I kept until Christmas of 1995 when I had a tank crash. It didn't grow much, it was yellowy brown, but it survived.

Also, the whole different strains of RTN and talking about it like it's a known and specific disease feels kind of off to me. RTN is not really a disease as much a symptom of various stressors and the result of those. Perhaps I missed some scientific breakthrough along the way, but I don't think any particular pathogen can be associated with all RTN.

 

[Ike]

Articles about the history of corals are always my favorite! This was a really rare treat for me to read, and definitely will remember it.

For some reason, I thought purple people eaters were the first named corals. Guess I was wrong, or maybe they were the first named zoanthids?

The PPE came about in 2001. It did play a big part in the zoanthid naming boom and the popularity of zoanthids as a whole.

 

[stunreefer]

I had seen Acropora in wholesalers tanks as far back as 1990, and I'm quite certain they were being imported well before that. Maybe I'm wrong, but I can recall Acropora being available from a few of the higher end fish stores as early as 1986.

I tend to agree with you here... I have to imagine someone, somewhere, had Acropora in their aquarium. I know for certain that I've seen pictures of Acropora skeletons in aquariums prior to that, and want to believe they were initially imported alive. Alas, the quote is Steve's recollection of the time, and at the time you mentioned seeing Acro's in wholesalers tanks (1990) I was 5

I had what I believed to be an A. samoensis colony that I received in the summer of 1991 from International Seaboard in Chicago that I kept until Christmas of 1995 when I had a tank crash. It didn't grow much, it was yellowy brown, but it survived.

Awesome! Growing, not growing... you did a heck of a thing for the time just keeping it alive based on what "we" knew.

Also, the whole different strains of RTN and talking about it like it's a known and specific disease feels kind of off to me. RTN is not really a disease as much a symptom of various stressors and the result of those. Perhaps I missed some scientific breakthrough along the way, but I don't think any particular pathogen can be associated with all RTN.

Again, I tend to agree with you here. RTN or STN can certainly be caused directly or indirectly by a myriad of things, generally resulting in anecdotal reports we see of "this additive killed my Acro!". With that said I do believe specific pathogens can be directly associated with massive RTN events, however at this point "we" don't know what they are, or how they get here. I've seen said mass events on the wholesale, retail and hobbyist side in systems that were absolutely thriving, and for no particular reason, RTN ensued. Take for example the massive RTN event that occurred in Sanjay's reef here recently. This is just one reason I run U/V on my reef systems; although I run them to directly fight off specific ailments, we really don't know everything we're trying to fight off. Better safe than sorry, IMHO.

 

[AquariumSpecialty]

The 1st acro I ever had came in by accident. I was in a store in Clt. NC called Inland Oceans. They had a double head colony of bright yellow leather coral (Sarcophyton elegans). In between the two heads was a tiny little nub of stony coral (only 1 polyp) that I had never seen in an aquarium store before. It was so small at 1st I wasn't sure what it was so I asked Tim, the owner, if he thought it was an acroporo species. He didn't know and didn't seem to care about it so I asked him how much the yellow leather corals were. He said it was $130.00 and the then owner of the Charlotte Hornets was planning to come in and buy it for his restaurant aquarium later that day. Well, I couldn't let that happen so I bought it and took it home on a chance that I could keep the nub alive and it would become what I though it was.

The nub grew into a colony and I later fragged it dozens of times and sold these frags to stores around the Carolinas for a few years before I eventually lost the colony. I'm not 100% positive what species of acro it was but it most closely resembled Acropora kirstyae and I couldn't find anything else that it looked like. I never gave it a fancy name but stores in the Carolinas wanted every piece I could frag. The year was 1992 when I found the "nub".