Id switch to rodi this very well could be the issue hereLFS RO….never tap
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
Id switch to rodi this very well could be the issue hereLFS RO….never tap
I have all those cleaners except the worms, and the LFS suggested doing it in increments over 4-6 weeks to not shock the tank until it’s all out then add the new sand so no old will mix with new.While you can, you still have the sediment and detritus within and just mixing with new.
As for what can turn over the sand. . . Nassarius snails, and sand sifting stars and what I don't favor but bristle worms
It is RODI from my LFS. They are a very reputable LFS in my area if their water was an issue all their clients would have this problem. Plus I have checked it with Hanna and no phosphate issues.Id switch to rodi this very well could be the issue here
How deep is your sand bed? I don't think you ever said. Having just an inch or so of sand is different than having a "deep sand bed" of several inches. The deep sand bed develops anaerobic bacteria activity in the deeper parts of the sand bed. If I remember correctly, the bacteria turn nitrate into nitrogen gas, and this is what can be released if you disturb the deeper parts of the deep sand bed. You may not have the same issues if you have a fairly shallow sand bed.That’s pretty much what my LFS guy said as well that if the sand bed is in long enough it could raise nitrates and phosphates…after me telling him everything I’ve tried to lower the phosphates that is when he asked how old is the sand bed because he said between my light regiment my feeding and that I run rowaphos in a reactor that is the only thing that could be the problem that the old sand bed is trapping the phosphates and then releasing them into the water.
It’s deeper in some areas than others but my deepest is maybe 3 inches or so but other areas are not as deep.How deep is your sand bed? I don't think you ever said. Having just an inch or so of sand is different than having a "deep sand bed" of several inches. The deep sand bed develops anaerobic bacteria activity in the deeper parts of the sand bed. If I remember correctly, the bacteria turn nitrate into nitrogen gas, and this is what can be released if you disturb the deeper parts of the deep sand bed. You may not have the same issues if you have a fairly shallow sand bed.
Maybe check with a tds checker just to make sure? Maybe a silica test kit also.It is RODI from my LFS. They are a very reputable LFS in my area if their water was an issue all their clients would have this problem. Plus I have checked it with Hanna and no phosphate issues.
Have you checked the tds in your fish stores water that you say is rodi that’s what I would do since you checked everything elseThe crazy part about all of this and while I appreciate all the suggestions these are things I have done to lower my phosphates to no avail, good cleaner crew, rowa phos in a reactor, less feeding, less lights, I’ve tried everything all have suggested except two things, syphon the bed or change it.
Do most agree that .16 is high and that’s what is causing my corals not to grow and spread like they should, most sites and my LFS says .16 is on the high side and could be a factor as to why the corals don’t grow like they should, if that’s not true then all of this talk is for not, meaning if .16 on average is not that high and not contributing to the lack of coral growth.
Haven’t read the whole post yet, in a nutshell what’s the safe way to do the whole bed?The sandbed isn't causing your coral issues
But as you can see, the advice to clean it in sections isn't safe, there's no fifty page thread handling them partially, that kills some people's whole tank. If you're going to do it do it right. The safe way shown is full tank disassembly
I don't think it will make your corals grow better at all, it's just the only safe way to handle truly deep old beds
Post a picture of your reef let's see it
Had a LFS suggest that solely on that he likes bare bottom and said he would do it in half an hour. Now 2 things wrong with that 1 my sand is in my rocks and he would have to rip my tank apart to get it all 2 that would blow up my tank. I told him this and he still said he wanted to do this he said that he can hold my corals in his tanks (which were covered in algea and aptasia). Let's just say I dont go there anymore.I have a 90 gallon with about a 3-inch sand bed that's over 10 years old, but no phosphate problems. A few years ago I hired a professional to come in and do some work on the tank and he suggested removing the sand bed simply because he doesn't like them, he prefers bare bottom. But he did say that the sand bed should be removed a little at a time because it's going to release certain compounds into the water and you don't want them to spike too high. Never got into a discussion of the specifics on that, though.