Salifert magnesium test kit instruction change?

[WildReefGuy]

So my instructions in my salifert magnesium test kit got lost. And everywhere online it had different instructions on how to test the exp. Date on mine is 5/2025 does anyone know what the correct instructions are? I’ve seen multiple ones say to use 4,5, and 6 drops of mg1.

 

[Crofty]

 

[WildReefGuy]

View attachment 2984654

Yea and then when I look it up online on the actual salifert website they have a pdf and it says 6 drops of MG1

 

[Crofty]

I was just about to test my Mg lol. Let me know if you can zoom in on that pic well enough to read it.

 

[ReeferCO]

Here are the directions from my old kit and my new kit. Both say 5 drops

 

[Crofty]

My kit expires 10/2025 and I bought it a couple months ago.

 

[Crofty]

It's a titration kit, so the 5 or 6 drops of the indicator shouldn't make a difference anyway.

 

[DivingTheWorld]

12/2024 5 drops. Mine have always been 5 drops over the years.

 

[anthonygf]

It's a titration kit, so the 5 or 6 drops of the indicator shouldn't make a difference anyway.

Mg-1 is not the indicator, Mg-3 in the old kit and Mg-2 in the new are the indicators.

 

[Crofty]

Mg-1 is not the indicator, Mg-3 in the old kit and Mg-2 in the new are the indicators.

Mg 2 is the titrant, used to quantitate the magnesium in the sample by volume. It's not the indicator, at least by the definition I'm accustomed to. The indicator (color changing component in the reaction) would be in Mg 1.

 

[anthonygf]

Mg 2 is the titrant, used to quantitate the magnesium in the sample by volume. It's not the indicator, at least by the definition I'm accustomed to. The indicator (color changing component in the reaction) would be in Mg 1.

I don't get it. I would think that the indicator would be the one that causes color change with each drop, then I would think that Mg-1 if even off by one drop would make a difference in test results. I apologize for trying to correct you for something I thought needed correcting. Shows you how much I know. Thank you for correcting me.

 

[Crofty]

I don't get it. I would think that the indicator would be the one that causes color change with each drop, then I would think that Mg-1 if even off by one drop would make a difference in test results. I apologize for trying to correct you for something I thought needed correcting. Shows you how much I know. Thank you for correcting me.

It's not at all intuitive how titration analysis work

The indicator isn't necessarily a key part of the reaction going on when you do the test. Rather it is a chemical that can change color based on the equilibrium between the magnesium in your sample and the titrant you are adding drop by drop. So if you have a little more or less indicator present, it might make your color change a little brighter or obvious, but it's not going to change how many drops it takes to get there.

Hope that makes a little sense as a simplifed explanation. Titration reactions can be quite complex and involved. And I'm not that great at explaining things..

 

[anthonygf]

It's not at all intuitive how titration analysis work

The indicator isn't necessarily a key part of the reaction going on when you do the test. Rather it is a chemical that can change color based on the equilibrium between the magnesium in your sample and the titrant you are adding drop by drop. So if you have a little more or less indicator present, it might make your color change a little brighter or obvious, but it's not going to change how many drops it takes to get there.

Hope that makes a little sense as a simplifed explanation. Titration reactions can be quite complex and involved. And I'm not that great at explaining things..

I remembered just now while laying in bed. I haven't used Salifert Mg in awhile. Mg 1 is like the dye (indicator), correct? So I was way off and an extra drop will not make a difference, sorry about that.
You explained that very well.