Long term reviews for Simplicity Dc 120/240 skimmers?

[Ziggy17]

Just wondering if anyone wants to share their long term 3+ years review on their simplicity skimmer? I’m looking at buying a DC option to replace my older BM curve 3.5 with a quieter option. The BM still works well but the pump is louder than I’d like and I’m hoping to get a newer unit that pulls more skim as well. The Simplicity unit is sold for $300 here in Canada, so if the reviews are great, it’s a very good option for my current budget. Looking for both positive and negative reviews.

Thanks for the input guys.

Zig.

 

[Reefer Matt]

Just wondering if anyone wants to share their long term 3+ years review on their simplicity skimmer? I’m looking at buying a DC option to replace my older BM curve 3.5 with a quieter option. The BM still works well but the pump is louder than I’d like and I’m hoping to get a newer unit that pulls more skim as well. The Simplicity unit is sold for $300 here in Canada, so if the reviews are great, it’s a very good option for my current budget. Looking for both positive and negative reviews.

Thanks for the input guys.

Zig.

I have four Simplicity skimmers. Three dc120, and one dc240. The oldest is six years, the newest is two years old. These work great as long as they are kept clean. I clean the cups once a week and the body once a year. They are quiet and efficient. No problems with any of them.

 

[Ziggy17]

I have four Simplicity skimmers. Three dc120, and one dc240. The oldest is six years, the newest is two years old. These work great as long as they are kept clean. I clean the cups once a week and the body once a year. They are quiet and efficient. No problems with any of them.

Appreciate that. I d pull my BM and clean the impeller/ body once a quarter, the cup is usually once a month, so hopefully that would in line with what you’re recommending on the Simplicity. Do they have a rubber footing to dampen the noice transfer from the body to the sump floor?

 

[Reefer Matt]

Appreciate that. I d pull my BM and clean the impeller/ body once a quarter, the cup is usually once a month, so hopefully that would in line with what you’re recommending on the Simplicity. Do they have a rubber footing to dampen the noice transfer from the body to the sump floor?

I honestly haven’t noticed if they have rubber feet, but there isn’t a lot of noise from them. I can verify later when I get home, but they are pretty quiet. I made a video on adjusting them and can share it if you’d like.

 

[Ziggy17]

I honestly haven’t noticed if they have rubber feet, but there isn’t a lot of noise from them. I can verify later when I get home, but they are pretty quiet. I made a video on adjusting them and can share it if you’d like.

Cheers. I actually did some digging around on here prior to posting and came across your video. Quite helpful. I figure I’ll just place it in a bucket with tank water from the next water change and run it until it breaks in. The advantage of not waiting till the current gear breaks before you evergreen..

 

[Reefer Matt]

Cheers. I actually did some digging around on here prior to posting and came across your video. Quite helpful. I figure I’ll just place it in a bucket with tank water from the next water change and run it until it breaks in. The advantage of not waiting till the current gear breaks before you evergreen..

I honestly didn’t have to wait long with these. If I remember correctly, it was a few days to start pulling good skimmate. Your mileage might vary though. But keeping the cup necks clean and minor adjustments help keep them running smooth. Good luck!

 

[Reign1]

I have had a 120 on a very old 90 gallon for around 3years Skimmer works great. I do have to take apart to clean regularly . Great skimmer for price point ..

 

[Ziggy17]

Also caught in between getting the 120 or the 240. I have a RS Reefer 300 with about 70g of total water volume with sump less rocks and sand, with a fairly heavily stocked tank with plans for more coral. I’ve read that an undersized skimmer is better than an oversized for pulling skim but my bioload may ramp up for a 240 eventually.

 

[don_pips]

Also caught in between getting the 120 or the 240. I have a RS Reefer 300 with about 70g of total water volume with sump less rocks and sand, with a fairly heavily stocked tank with plans for more coral. I’ve read that an undersized skimmer is better than an oversized for pulling skim but my bioload may ramp up for a 240 eventually.

the simplicity IMO is an ok skimmer it really depends on your budget. I have a 240 on my 120 gallon tank. not an easy skimmer to adjust properly. i constantly have to tweak it. when its running well it pulls out alot. that being said for a little more money id go with something else. Reef octopus or nyos is your best bet. I regret buying the simplicity for another 150 bucks you can have a more reliable work horse skimmer. Dont waste your money. buy right or buy twice.