High Potassium Experience

forestsofkelp

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 28, 2019
Messages
179
Reaction score
141
Location
Southern California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
OK, if anybody is wondering what happens when you have a really high potassium level, I can tell you. I have a mixed reef, with tangs, anthias, wrasses and clowns. This was not an experiment, just a result of stubbornness and not taking advice.

K 5-600 anthias die

700-800: Clams appear unhappy. Wrasses die

900: tangs die. Acros begin losing tissue. Some montis bleached. Clams die. Things die rapidly.

My gem tang and clowns were unaffected. Most of my corals looked fine or unhappy... some of my acros and LPS had less PE. 1 of 3 montis began to bleach. My Maxima clam was partially closed; my gigas clam gaped and died

I attribute it to K since ll the fish behaved normally, looked normal, then would lose appetite for 2 days and just die, or disappear. No abnormalities, worms etc on post mortem exams.

The reason my potassium was high is because I switched to an alkalinity supplement with potassium in it. I did the initial math wrong and overdosed. My k went from 450 to 600 then hovered there for a few months; I attributed problems at that level to anthias fighting leading to attrition.

It slowly began to climb/fluctuate over the next 2-3 months and I lost a wrasse or two but did not connect it the high K.

Then 2 weeks ago I got an ICP back...it spiked to 900 (no dosing change) and stuff had just started dying daily. I picked out my scopes tang, my clam, then the next day my powder blue tang. I realized prior issues were probably due to my high potassium. My CUC (which is small) was less active. Snails were on the ground, writhing.

I immediately did 3x 30% water change. Repeat ICP is being sent tomorrow. My remaining clam immediately opened up and was happier.. I think it will get me down to 500, which is fine as far as I am concerned. Hopefully in the next two weeks I'll see how everything recovers. Looking forward to that ICP coming back looking much better.

So if anyone is wondering how high you can get potassium before it really starts to get bad...900
 

MnFish1

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 28, 2016
Messages
24,326
Reaction score
23,111
Location
Midwest
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
OK, if anybody is wondering what happens when you have a really high potassium level, I can tell you. I have a mixed reef, with tangs, anthias, wrasses and clowns. This was not an experiment, just a result of stubbornness and not taking advice.

K 5-600 anthias die

700-800: Clams appear unhappy. Wrasses die

900: tangs die. Acros begin losing tissue. Some montis bleached. Clams die. Things die rapidly.

My gem tang and clowns were unaffected. Most of my corals looked fine or unhappy... some of my acros and LPS had less PE. 1 of 3 montis began to bleach. My Maxima clam was partially closed; my gigas clam gaped and died

I attribute it to K since ll the fish behaved normally, looked normal, then would lose appetite for 2 days and just die, or disappear. No abnormalities, worms etc on post mortem exams.

The reason my potassium was high is because I switched to an alkalinity supplement with potassium in it. I did the initial math wrong and overdosed. My k went from 450 to 600 then hovered there for a few months; I attributed problems at that level to anthias fighting leading to attrition.

It slowly began to climb/fluctuate over the next 2-3 months and I lost a wrasse or two but did not connect it the high K.

Then 2 weeks ago I got an ICP back...it spiked to 900 (no dosing change) and stuff had just started dying daily. I picked out my scopes tang, my clam, then the next day my powder blue tang. I realized prior issues were probably due to my high potassium. My CUC (which is small) was less active. Snails were on the ground, writhing.

I immediately did 3x 30% water change. Repeat ICP is being sent tomorrow. My remaining clam immediately opened up and was happier.. I think it will get me down to 500, which is fine as far as I am concerned. Hopefully in the next two weeks I'll see how everything recovers. Looking forward to that ICP coming back looking much better.

So if anyone is wondering how high you can get potassium before it really starts to get bad...900
It could very well be the potassium. I would watch your other fish, etc - in case the stress of moving, etc - causes a problem - or in case it was more than one issue. There are videos, etc out there that say that 900 may not be a problem - and others that say >450 or so is a problem. Your rising levels may relate to less organisms using the potassium (since some died off) - or the storage areas for potassium may have become saturated and there was no other place for it to go except rise in the water to high levels.
 

Randy Holmes-Farley

Reef Chemist
View Badges
Joined
Sep 5, 2014
Messages
72,100
Reaction score
69,741
Location
Massachusetts, United States
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
OK, if anybody is wondering what happens when you have a really high potassium level, I can tell you. I have a mixed reef, with tangs, anthias, wrasses and clowns. This was not an experiment, just a result of stubbornness and not taking advice.

K 5-600 anthias die

700-800: Clams appear unhappy. Wrasses die

900: tangs die. Acros begin losing tissue. Some montis bleached. Clams die. Things die rapidly.

My gem tang and clowns were unaffected. Most of my corals looked fine or unhappy... some of my acros and LPS had less PE. 1 of 3 montis began to bleach. My Maxima clam was partially closed; my gigas clam gaped and died

I attribute it to K since ll the fish behaved normally, looked normal, then would lose appetite for 2 days and just die, or disappear. No abnormalities, worms etc on post mortem exams.

The reason my potassium was high is because I switched to an alkalinity supplement with potassium in it. I did the initial math wrong and overdosed. My k went from 450 to 600 then hovered there for a few months; I attributed problems at that level to anthias fighting leading to attrition.

It slowly began to climb/fluctuate over the next 2-3 months and I lost a wrasse or two but did not connect it the high K.

Then 2 weeks ago I got an ICP back...it spiked to 900 (no dosing change) and stuff had just started dying daily. I picked out my scopes tang, my clam, then the next day my powder blue tang. I realized prior issues were probably due to my high potassium. My CUC (which is small) was less active. Snails were on the ground, writhing.

I immediately did 3x 30% water change. Repeat ICP is being sent tomorrow. My remaining clam immediately opened up and was happier.. I think it will get me down to 500, which is fine as far as I am concerned. Hopefully in the next two weeks I'll see how everything recovers. Looking forward to that ICP coming back looking much better.

So if anyone is wondering how high you can get potassium before it really starts to get bad...900

Thanks for the info!
 
Back
Top