Lighting Upgrades Affecting Corals

[Ty.S44]

I've recently gotten a 190 gallon aquarium up and running with a 6 bulb T5 fixture on top of it, and I plan on introducing corals. My issue is deciding when, and one factor, I'm hoping this forum can help resolve, is my lighting situation. Since this fixture isn't dimmable, I can't dial the intensity back on them to account for more light. I'm worried that upgrades such as new bulbs (this particular fixture is used, and I believe needs new bulbs) or new LEDs will force me to change the placement of the corals that would already have been present in the tank. This is what I'm trying to avoid.

With all that being said, does this mean I need to wait until I have what I'd consider my end goal of a lighting system until I introduce corals to my tank? Or are there other options I'm not considering?

 

[Hurricane Aquatics]

I've recently gotten a 190 gallon aquarium up and running with a 6 bulb T5 fixture on top of it, and I plan on introducing corals. My issue is deciding when, and one factor, I'm hoping this forum can help resolve, is my lighting situation. Since this fixture isn't dimmable, I can't dial the intensity back on them to account for more light. I'm worried that upgrades such as new bulbs (this particular fixture is used, and I believe needs new bulbs) or new LEDs will force me to change the placement of the corals that would already have been present in the tank. This is what I'm trying to avoid.

With all that being said, does this mean I need to wait until I have what I'd consider my end goal of a lighting system until I introduce corals to my tank? Or are there other options I'm not considering?

One of the great things about T5 is you mount it around 6 to 10 inches over the tank and it's good. No dimming needed.

I would run the T5 as it is with new bulbs and then you could add some led strips or something later. A 6 bulb T5 should be perfect for most to any corals assuming the T5 covers the whole tank.

 

[Ty.S44]

One of the great things about T5 is you mount it around 6 to 10 inches over the tank and it's good. No dimming needed.

I would run the T5 as it is with new bulbs and then you could add some led strips or something later. A 6 bulb T5 should be perfect for most to any corals assuming the T5 covers the whole tank.

Thanks that was actually pretty much what I was thinking although I had not considered mounting height.The T5 fixture does run the whole length of the tank.
I actually neglected to mention two things. My tank has a 30in*30in cross section, and that the fixture I'm running does have two channels controlling 3 bulbs each programmed independently.
Not sure if that bit of info changes your opinion, but I appreciate the quick response.

 

[EeyoreIsMySpiritAnimal]

I think you'll be fine, but if you're worried about new bulbs being too much of a PAR increase, you can always change them out at different times, say 2 each month..

 

[Hurricane Aquatics]

Thanks that was actually pretty much what I was thinking although I had not considered mounting height.The T5 fixture does run the whole length of the tank.
I actually neglected to mention two things. My tank has a 30in*30in cross section, and that the fixture I'm running does have two channels controlling 3 bulbs each programmed independently.
Not sure if that bit of info changes your opinion, but I appreciate the quick response.

No, not really. That's pretty normal on the two channels. I would run them both at the same time unless you want to try different looks.

As far as corals, placement is key. Softies are usually near the bottom to mid. Same with LPS really. SPS of you go that route, are mid to high placement. T5's are one of the most forgiving lights you can use. It's a very diffuse lighting.

Would love to see it when you get ready. Sounds like you are going to have a really nice setup. Welcome to the forum.

 

[Ty.S44]

I think you'll be fine, but if you're worried about new bulbs being too much of a PAR increase, you can always change them out at different times, say 2 each month..

That does sound better than changing all at once. Thank you.

 

[Ty.S44]

No, not really. That's pretty normal on the two channels. I would run them both at the same time unless you want to try different looks.

As far as corals, placement is key. Softies are usually near the bottom to mid. Same with LPS really. SPS of you go that route, are mid to high placement. T5's are one of the most forgiving lights you can use. It's a very diffuse lighting.

Would love to see it when you get ready. Sounds like you are going to have a really nice setup. Welcome to the forum.

Thank you for all your input. Very much appreciated.
I'll see about making a tank build thread once I get a chance and I'll make sure to post a link on this thread.

 

[Lavey29]

One of the great things about T5 is you mount it around 6 to 10 inches over the tank and it's good. No dimming needed.

I would run the T5 as it is with new bulbs and then you could add some led strips or something later. A 6 bulb T5 should be perfect for most to any corals assuming the T5 covers the whole tank.

I'm not familiar with T5 lights but know they have been used on tanks for long time with success. Since they do not ramp up and down like LEDs do you typically run a shorter duration period of light like maybe 8 hours?

 

[Hurricane Aquatics]

I'm not familiar with T5 lights but know they have been used on tanks for long time with success. Since they do not ramp up and down like LEDs do you typically run a shorter duration period of light like maybe 8 hours?

No, I used to run them for 10 to 12. I mean the PAR range is the same so no reason to run them any different.

 

[Ty.S44]

I'm not familiar with T5 lights but know they have been used on tanks for long time with success. Since they do not ramp up and down like LEDs do you typically run a shorter duration period of light like maybe 8 hours?

Currently, and mind you I do not have corals in the tank at the moment, I am running this schedule with my two channels:

Channel 1: 10:00AM - 07:00PM (10:00 - 19:00)
Channel 2: 01:00PM - 10:00PM (13:00 - 22:00)

So, I have only the first channel active (50% intensity) for three hours, I have both channels active (100% intensity) for six hours, and only the second channel active (50% intensity) for the last three hours. This, of course, runs over a total of twelve hours.

 

[Lavey29]

Currently, and mind you I do not have corals in the tank at the moment, I am running this schedule with my two channels:

Channel 1: 10:00AM - 07:00PM (10:00 - 19:00)
Channel 2: 01:00PM - 10:00PM (13:00 - 22:00)

So, I have only the first channel active (50% intensity) for three hours, I have both channels active (100% intensity) for six hours, and only the second channel active (50% intensity) for the last three hours. This, of course, runs over a total of twelve hours.

Oh ok so you can kind of have a ramp up and down effect with T5 also

 

[Ty.S44]

Oh ok so you can kind of have a ramp up and down effect with T5 also

Yes, somewhat. It does allow me to have a little control over the total amount of light that enters the tank throughout the day.