DIY (Auto) FROZEN FOOD FEEDER

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This article is an overview and instructions for building a DIY Auto Frozen Feeder for your Aquarium.

What does it do?

  • It Feeds "Chilled...Always Fresh" Frozen Food to my 4 Fish Tanks Automatically.
  • Programmable "Variable Sized" Portions.
  • Programmable "Any time of day" Feedings.
  • Self Cleaning too!

This feeder was built so I can get away from Home and continue to feed my fish. I have a few Ehiem Pellet Flake Auto Feeders that I use while away. The issue is I have a Copperband Butterfly fish in each of my Tanks that won't eat Flake or Pellet Food (ie. strictly eat Frozen). After building and installing this feeder it works so well, I've set it up as a permanent Daily Feeder which now gives me near total hands off Automation on all my 4 tanks.

The feeder may look like a complex time machine that runs on a flux capacitor made to fit into the trunk of your DeLorean but you don’t have to wait for the future…it’s actually quite simple once you understand the basic concepts and you can make one for yourself.
2020-08-10_FinalFrozenFeedBuild-2-s.jpg

The main component of this feeder is a Koolatron Cooler to keep Frozen Food chilled, and it all runs on a few dosing heads. Water is pumped via tubes to get the food to the tank and ultimately to your fish.

I did NOT make the Koolatron (which is a purchase DC voltage Cooler for your Car). Plenty of models, sizes and prices to choose from.

Here is the one I used that I had spare.

This lower price model might work for a Single Tank Feeder.


I also did NOT make the Magnetic Stirrer.


I did make my doser, but you can buy your own DOSER too. LIke this one if building a Single Tank Feeder.


The rest I made with parts I had kicking around.

Let's move on.....

Feeder-Internal-Components-s.jpg

A closer look inside the Koolatron with cover removed that contains internal Components.
This article will describe my final design and will discuss some other options you can consider when building your own. Details on materials, construction tips and programming are included.


Want to get a quick overview before you read all the details.....



The feeder designed and discussed here was designed to feed my four tanks (as shown below), yet it will work just as well for a single tank or more than four Tanks. It’s determined by the number of dosing heads.


4TankFeederSetup.jpg


In an effort to make this easier to understand, here is a basic diagram showing the final design and components used. The setup and functionality are described below. I will refer to this diagram throughout the article.

FrozenFeeder_Article-Photo-Design-Concept.jpg

Preparation/Overview:
  • Fill the concentrate container (A) with your favorite frozen food (frozen pieces/cubes or rinsed frozen food in small amount of fresh water).
  • Note: the frozen food pieces (after melting) must be smaller than the diameter of the tube you are using to avoid clogging the feeding tubes. You may have to blend your chosen food to ensure the pieces are small enough.
  • Top off container (B) is filled with Pure Water since it will be the liquid to distribute food to your tank.
  • This same container (B) and water is used to automatically clean and flush out the feeding tubes after each feeding.
  • The food from (A) will pumped to the distribution container (C) and then pumped to the tank from there.
  • D3,D4-Dn are simple dosing pumps of your choosing. (# of Pumps depends on # Fish Tanks (F) you wish to set up)

FrozenFeederFoodPrep-1.jpg

Works with Most Frozen Foods (Tested with Mysis, and Brine Shrimp).....Food Can be Rinsed and Strained if desired

FrozenFeederFoodPrep-2.jpg

Careful to not use Large Chunk Frozen (it can Plug the pumps and tubes)


FrozenFeederFoodPrep-3.jpg

Coolers Take Time to Cool things down (So add things cold at the Start)​

Feeding Steps
  • (optional) Mix Frozen Food Concentrate
  • Dosing pump (D1) pumps the frozen concentrate from container (A) and adds it the distribution container (C)
  • Dosing pump (D2) pumps fresh water from container (B) to the distribution container (C), to dilute the concentrate.
  • At this point, dosing pump (D1-Dn) feed each tank tied in to your system.

FeederSteps-OptionalStep0-Mix.jpg

Magnetic Stirrer (Food Concentrate Container)

Optional: I chose to use a magnetic mixer to stir the feeding concentrate prior to each feeding cycle. After testing the feeder I learned that it does make feeding more consistant, but not really necessary if you want to cut on Costs or Space.

DosingTubeFlows.jpg

Dosing Pumps Flows​


Cleaning and Purging Steps
  • Dosing pump (D2) pumps fresh water from (B) to container (C)
  • The feedings pumps (D1-Dn) then pump the fresh water to the tanks to purge the feeding lines




The Full Feed Cycle Illustrated:

FeederSteps.jpg

As you can see in the Running Demo Photos above, the Distribution Container is relatively Clean of food after Final Rinse and Flush.​

NOTE: The final cleaning and purging step is an important element in the design. All the food and tubes within the cooler are chilled. The tubes going to the fish tanks are obviously not. If there is trapped food in the feeding tubes going to the tank(s) it has the potential to spoil in between feedings since they are not temperature controlled. This is true even if the distance between your feeder and tank is very short. Please do not skip the cleaning and purging steps.

Doser Heads and Connections:

Whether you’re working with one tank or multiple, your design will have to accommodate having at least one dosing head (D1) located inside the cooler. Since that dosing head is transferring the concentrate there is no way to flush/purge that line after each use, therefore it needs to stay cooled.

Since my particular auto feeder is feeding multiple tanks, I was unable to fit multiple dosing heads inside the cooler. With some basic electronic wiring skills, you can remove dosing heads form any multi-headed doser and extend the wires. If only designing the auto feeder for one tank, most smaller three-headed dosers will likely fit in your cooler. This is something to keep in mind when designing your system.

In the picture below of my prototype, it illustrates how the doser heads are configured – one internal and the others external to the cooler. The magnetic stirrer, three containers and one dosing head are inside the cooler.

2020-08-06_4TankFeederSetup.jpg

Protoype DIY Frozen Fix Food Feeder


Programming Dosers:

The programming will vary with each setup and it unique to each feeder. So it’s not reasonable to discuss all the options and maintain your interest. But here are a few key factors to consider when doing your programming:
  • The amount of food you wish to feed
  • The concentration of your prepared food
  • Programming can vary on portions/times of feedings (Breakfast, lunch or dinner time)
  • Programming can vary by tank as wel
  • Dilution water you use
  • Distance to tank from auto feeder

Now for some programming Details:
  • [DOSE 1: Concentrate Pump D1] – this is where you simply program how much food you will feed the tank(s).
    • This dosing amounts will depend on Food Portion Size.
  • [DOSE 2: The Dilute WATER PUMP D2]
    • Is just enough Dosing volume to loosen up the contrentrate a tiny bit with water. It' a mini first flush of the distribution container.
  • [DOSE 3: Feed Pump D3, D4,...]
    • Is enough Dosing Volume to COMPLETELY drain the distribution container ( DOSE 1 + DOSE 2)
    • You DON'T have to Dose long enough to get Food to the Tank (The Purge Dose 5 will get food there)
  • [DOSE 4: Flush WATER PUMP D2]
    • In enough Dosing Volume to add some Rinse/Flush Water for Last DOSE 5.
    • This Rinses the Distribution Container. So the amount must be a bit more than ( DOSE 1 + DOSE 2)
  • [DOSE 5: Clean/Purge Program : FEED PUMP AGAIN D3]
    • This Dosing Volume will depend on the distance to your tank. (Roughly = 2x Distance to Tank+DOSE 4)
    • You will be dosing any remaining food, Rinse Water, and a push to purge the dosing lines completly.

NOTE: [The Dose 5] (Clean/Purge/Flush) should be about double the length of the tube (distance to the tank). This ensures the line is not only clear of FOOD & Flush Water, but the tubes are purged and only full of air until the next feeding.

I also learned during testing that you don't need to add that much water (to completely fill the Tube Length) for the flush, since when water runs out the flush will continue with Air, and flush out the ALL the water anyway. (This saves on the size of the Water Container).


Components and Assembly

Let’s discuss what actually makes this thing work so well. In my case, I was able to utilize things I had on hand at the house. I’ll share some photos of the parts and the assembly components.

I’ll start by sharing some photos of the feeder disassembled.

2020-08-11_DissasembledParts.jpg


2020-08-11_DissasembledParts 2.jpg


The Auto Frozen Fish Feeder Disassembled

For the containers that will handle the food (Items A and C in the first diagram), you want to find something that has a funnel shape to it. This will assure the food settles near the bottom of the container which is where the dosing pumps tubes connect. In my case, I used an Iced Tea Bottle, installed upside down. The cap is the perfect size for the magnetic stir impeller. The other added benefit is it is easily replaced if/when the gunk builds up. I love Iced Tea so I don’t mind having another bottle to keep the feeder fresh and clean.

The top off water container (Item B in the first diagram) I used a Kamoer Dosing Container. It’s a large volume container and with its rectangular shape, it fits perfectly in the cooler.

The bottom of the cooler has egg crate that the Electronic Magnetic Stirrer sits on. Having the Stirrer up off the actual bottom of the cooler protects it from any accidental spill or liquid condensation that settles on the bottom. (NOTE: The more you open and peek into the Cooler, warm moist air will get into the cooler, and the more you will get condenstate dripping off the Cold Cooling Fins and containers)

Since we all have some Styrofoam lying around from our last fish or coral order, I discovered it works perfectly for mounting equipment and positioning things correctly and firmly in place. Just cut pieces to fit your varying conditions. Nothing is glued and installed permanently. As long as it fits snuggly it’s not going anywhere and it makes things easier to take apart for the occasional cleaning and/or maintenance.

I used wider diameter and stiffer RO tubing for the dosing line HOLDERS. Just cut some slits in the STIFF RO TUBING mentioned above and use a drop or two of hot glue to hold in place. The softer Air Line tubing will snap in. Try to keep from installing anything permanently as mentioned above. The same stiffer tubing was used to position the floppy tube at the bottom of the Concentrate Container in an effort to keep the tube on the bottom of the container at all times. This is important so it doesn’t get out of position during the stir.

Important to note, if you’re using tubing couplers you may need to enlarge the whole so you don’t end up with food getting lodged in the couplers. In my case, the couplers were too narrow so I drilled them out to enlarge the holes.
2020-08-11_DrilledOutConnectors.jpg

Don’t forget to enlarge the tube couplers if necessary

Here is a quick overview on the OPTIONAL Magenetic Stirrer Setup, if you choose to add one to your design.

  • Basically the Ice Tea Bottle is Inverted to hold the Thick Concentrate.​
  • Top of Bottle is cut open to add the Frozen Food and a small amount of Water.​
  • The Frozen Food will slowly settle to the bottom of the Container, and water will be at the top.​
  • The Magnetic Stir Pellet fits inside the Cap and it spins inside once the Magenetic Stirrer is activated. Mixing up the food and water.​
MageneticStirrerConcentrateMixer.jpg

Magentic Stirrer for the Frozen Concentrate Container Mixing
Now you don't want to just plug in the Stirrer and have it running all the time. You could but it's pointless, and it may grind and over liquify the frozen pieces.
So you need to turn it on every so often, and most importantly a minute before the Feeding Cycle starts. This will ensure the food concentrate is evenly distrubuted and each feeding is consistant. Otherwise your early feeding will be heavier, and the last feeding will be light. It's not perfect but that's the idea.

Since your Doser can't control the Magentic Stirrer, you can use a timer, and the program your stir and feed accordingly.

MagneticStirrerTimers.jpg

Magentic Stirrer Timer Options



Okay, so we have our Auto Feeder set up, it’s time to run the lines to the tank(s). Then you'll have to adjust your Flush program once you finalized the tube lengths to your tank. ( Remember the last program is the purge and is distance dependant )

This is my setup as seen from the Back of the Cooler.

FeederFinalHookup.jpg

Feeding Tube to Dosing Head Distrubution

You need to consider where the feeding output tube is installed in your tank(s). It’s important to make sure the food is either spread throughout the tank or I a feeding ring so the inhabitants can crab it before the overflow does.

I do have a feeding ring on one of my tanks so that’s where the output tube is installed. On another tank which doesn’t have a feeding ring, I placed the output tube right in front of a power head.

FeedingTubeToTankFeedingSpot.jpg

Feeding Tube Output Installtion Options (Above Water Surface or Below Water Surfice)

The other two tanks are too far from the auto feeder and would require a very long tube to reach them on the floor above the sumps. I’m lucky that both sumps are in the basement and close to the feeder. For those two, I simply placed the output tube (under water) next to the return pump inlet . The return pump takes care of the rest.

FeederOutputTOreturnPump.jpg

Feeding Output tube installed at the input of the return pump and the food is pumped to the tank Upstairs.



To close, I thought I’d share a couple ideas I had that I didn’t implement. I figured I’d share them in case a reader decides to build their own Auto Feeder and may be able to incorporate some different ideas. These additional concepts as well as designs other folks come up with can be discussed in the comments.

FeederOtherDesigns-1.jpg

Simple Design (Downside, No Cleaning)

FeederOtherDesigns-2.jpg

Complex DESIGN (Bi-Directional Doser Needed) for Reversing Pump Direction to Return Food to Reservoir.​


That covers off all I wanted to convey on the feeder design.


Summary:

I have been running the feeder for a couple of weeks and it works perfect. The longest I ran it unattended was 5 days while away from home, and it almost ran out of food and water. So I'm working fine tuning the Food Concentrate Concentration, and fine tuning the dilution and flush amounts to last longer.

The feeder airline tubes are perfectly clean with the flushing cycle, even my longest run which is 12 feet to my sump that sends food via the return pump to my upstairs tank.

The ONLY DOWNSIDE I see after running the Frozen Feeder for a while is the Fish have become trained on it, and now the fish love it more than me :) They sense the food is coming and hang around the feeder output spots. They don't freak out as much every time they see me going to the Fridge, or get close to the tank. At least they don't beg so that means I'm not suckered into feeding them too much. The feeder runs regularily few times a day and same small portions.
I hope you have enjoyed reading about my adventure in creating a DIY Frozen Fish Feeder. It was a fun project and I’m sure as time goes on I will make adjustments to it. I would love to see what others have come up with for their own feeders. Feel free to ask questions and share your own projects.
 
Last edited:

RobB'z Reef

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 23, 2020
Messages
2,783
Reaction score
5,775
Location
Eau Claire
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Interesting, can't fault your technical skills and inspiration one bit! I had to get through the entire thing though to understand the point of why... BLUF. Bottom line up front. You never explained what your goal was or what problem you were trying to solve until the very end. Lol, that being said other than the annoying read it's a brilliant solution. Be interested to see how it holds up over time. I travel a lot and could ultimately take inspiration from this. Nicely designed (A+), presentation (B-). You posted this so I assumed you're looking for honest feedback. Overall kick butt!

*Edit - btw, I in no way mean meant to diminish your accomplishment. It's absolutely brilliant. Just trying to help you polish your presentation.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Interesting, can't fault your technical skills and inspiration one bit! I had to get through the entire thing though to understand the point of why... BLUF. Bottom line up front. You never explained what your goal was or what problem you were trying to solve until the very end. Lol, that being said other than the annoying read it's a brilliant solution. Be interested to see how it holds up over time. I travel a lot and could ultimately take inspiration from this. Nicely designed (A+), presentation (B-). You posted this so I assumed you're looking for honest feedback. Overall kick butt!

*Edit - btw, I in no way mean meant to diminish your accomplishment. It's absolutely brilliant. Just trying to help you polish your presentation.

I appreciate the postiive and constructive feedback. This is still in Draft Edit before they take an post as an article.
It's still not a posted article so feel free on how to improve. I really struggled to keep it simple, but provide as much detail to give someone a head start on building their own. Sounds like I missed the why I made it. Anything else?

So I just added this to the opening.

This feeder was built so I can get away from Home and continue to feed my fish. I have a few Ehiem Pellet Flake Auto Feeders that I use while away from home. The issue is I have a Copperband Butterfly fish in each of my Tanks that won't eat flake or Pellet (ie strictly eat Frozen). After building and installing this feeder it works so well, I've set it up as a permanent Daily Feeder which now gives me near total hands off Automation on all my 4 tanks.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Nicely designed (A+), presentation (B-).
*Edit - btw, I in no way mean meant to diminish your accomplishment. It's absolutely brilliant. Just trying to help you polish your presentation.
Hey @Rob.bucek
You helped. You helped a lot....
I just read the intro and it's also missing a brief intro/overview so just added this....

What does it do?
  • It Feeds "Always Fresh Frozen Food" to my 4 Fish Tanks Automatically.
  • Programmable "Variable Sized" Portions.
  • Programmable "Any time of day" Feedings.
  • Self Cleaning too!
Do I get a B for writing now? LOL
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Wow Wally. You never cease to amaze me. Will you post video of it in action?
Thanks @ScottR for the very nice comment.
I certainly will post a video. Already made it but needs some editing, and will be much less work the the write up.
The video is cool to see the fish in anticipation and go nuts when food arrives. Also how well the final design works and how well the distribution lines work at long distances too, to keep clean with the Flush cycle.
 

dbl

It Takes Less Energy to be Nice
View Badges
Joined
Mar 13, 2014
Messages
15,945
Reaction score
90,221
Location
SW Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Great job @WallyB and what a great solution finally for feeding frozen while away.
 

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
6,449
Reaction score
6,945
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
@WallyB

Very impressive. Reads like a doctoral thesis! LOL Seems very complicated to build.

Did I miss it? What was the cost of assembling this and how many hours of labor went into the build?

But I do have a question that I've wondered about when thinking about how I would build an auto feeder for frozen foods...

Why must we keep the food chilled? Are we worried about our fish becoming ill by eating spoiled food?
 
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
@WallyB

Very impressive. Reads like a doctoral thesis! LOL Seems very complicated to build.

Did I miss it? What was the cost of assembling this and how many hours of labor went into the build?

But I do have a question that I've wondered about when thinking about how I would build an auto feeder for frozen foods...

Why must we keep the food chilled? Are we worried about our fish becoming ill by eating spoiled food?
Thanks @Dom,

I,m gettting the feeling I over wrote and made The Frozen Feeder look more complicated than it is.
I'm an Engineer not a Writer. So I wrote the Detailed Guide. This Project needs a quick start leaflet.

For a Single Tank Feeder.
It can be built in less than a couple of hours. Tops three hours. That includes installation and programming.
Most of that time is wandering thru your Junk or Dollar Stores to find parts.

I will do a video that will simpilfy the wordy explanation.

As far as your question (why keep Frozen Food Chilled). Ever smell melted frozen next day? YUCK!!
 
Last edited:

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
6,449
Reaction score
6,945
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Thanks @Dom,
As far as your question (why keep Frozen Food Chilled). Ever smell melted frozen next day? YUCK!!

Yes, I have! But in a closed container, that problem is solved.

So if odor is the only reason, I would think building one without the cooling would reduce the cost and the complexity.

But a great job!
 
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
@WallyB

Did I miss it? What was the cost of assembling this and how many hours of labor went into the build?

Let me answer the Cost Question.

  • The version I built is the Cadillac Model and it feeds 4 tanks and has the optional Stirrer. Unlimited Powered Cooling.
  • Cost (roughly) for key components: $280 TOTAL (DC Cooler $133) (Stirrer $29) (Doser $100) (Parts $10)

However for a Single Tank, Budget model could be as low as $50 (depending what you have kicking around)
The only expensive part would be a need for 3 Dosing Heads (Spare heads or new purchase)

FeederBudgetModel.jpg


It's hard to give an accurate cost since it depends on what kind of Feeder you need.

You could potentially build one for $Free$ from Spare Parts you already have. (At least to try the concept for a Long Weekend Feeder)
 

Erick Armanii

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 31, 2017
Messages
809
Reaction score
714
Location
Danbury Ct
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is brilliant. I’ve been trying to work on something like this but was having a tough time figuring out how to keep the food from spoiling in the dosing lines.

would be interested in seeing a breakdown in a video to help better understand the process.

Also, I don’t know what the thread said before the edit but to me it’s quite obvious why someone would want to make an auto feeder..
 
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is brilliant. I’ve been trying to work on something like this but was having a tough time figuring out how to keep the food from spoiling in the dosing lines.

would be interested in seeing a breakdown in a video to help better understand the process.

Also, I don’t know what the thread said before the edit but to me it’s quite obvious why someone would want to make an auto feeder..
THanks for the Compliment.

And Thanks for the Motivation to Finish the Video.
It will show it all Much more Illustratively in about 5 minutes (A-Z in sequence)..... (And how simple and effective it really is)
 
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
COMING SOON (Frozen Feeder DEMO VIDEO) !!

I'm Uploading VIDEO to YouTUBE....

So I actually prepared a bunch of Video clips using my SLR Video CAM to splice together and provide overlay details.
I've (over) documented enough in this Article, so let's make this Sweet and Simple.

I just pulled out my phone, walked and talked and let the Feeder Run....

Hang in there....The upload is a bit slow with Family Consumining all the household Internet bandwidth.
 
Last edited:

siggy

My Aquariums Going Again
View Badges
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
7,124
Reaction score
21,423
Location
MI
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Wow! Thanks for sharing all the hard work.
 

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
6,449
Reaction score
6,945
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Let me answer the Cost Question.

  • The version I built is the Cadillac Model and it feeds 4 tanks and has the optional Stirrer. Unlimited Powered Cooling.
  • Cost (roughly) for key components: $280 TOTAL (DC Cooler $133) (Stirrer $29) (Doser $100) (Parts $10)

However for a Single Tank, Budget model could be as low as $50 (depending what you have kicking around)
The only expensive part would be a need for 3 Dosing Heads (Spare heads or new purchase)

It's hard to give an accurate cost since it depends on what kind of Feeder you need.

You could potentially build one for $Free$ from Spare Parts you already have. (At least to try the concept for a Long Weekend Feeder)

I've been working on a frozen food feeder where the frozen food mixed with RODI is placed in a 1000ml flask. Using a rubber stopper with two glass tubes, the first feeds down to the bottom of the flask and the second stops above the fluid line.

Using an air pump and a timer, air pressure is built up in the flask via the short rod, so that the frozen food is pushed through the long rod, through a tube and in to the tank.

But the problem is that as the level of food decreases, the run time of the air pump changes (the pump needs to run longer). So this project is ongoing...

I also tried using an "NG tube" (commonly known as a feeding tube in a hospital setting) with a refillable IV bag in conjunction with am IV pump that I pick up off of eBay for $59. But that was a bust as the pump is designed to deliver dosing at regular intervals throughout a 24 hour period.

What you have designed here addresses the issues I have encountered.

But why would you need one head per tank? Why couldn't you use one dosing head and split off its output to multiple tanks?

Dom
 
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've been working on a frozen food feeder where the frozen food mixed with RODI is placed in a 1000ml flask. Using a rubber stopper with two glass tubes, the first feeds down to the bottom of the flask and the second stops above the fluid line.

Using an air pump and a timer, air pressure is built up in the flask via the short rod, so that the frozen food is pushed through the long rod, through a tube and in to the tank.

But the problem is that as the level of food decreases, the run time of the air pump changes (the pump needs to run longer). So this project is ongoing...

I also tried using an "NG tube" (commonly known as a feeding tube in a hospital setting) with a refillable IV bag in conjunction with am IV pump that I pick up off of eBay for $59. But that was a bust as the pump is designed to deliver dosing at regular intervals throughout a 24 hour period.

What you have designed here addresses the issues I have encountered.

But why would you need one head per tank? Why couldn't you use one dosing head and split off its output to multiple tanks?

Dom
Interesting Altenative design. I really appreciate your inovative creativity. Certainly may be cheaper.

I can see where you have run into consistancy issues.
Running Pressure changes with each line taking different paths.
Air volume increases (As container empties) so it takes more pressure to compress the air and then push the heavier liquid/food-soup.
You could take your design (as is). Replace the Air Pump with a Dosing Pump. Seal your container but fill it full of water.
Then pump water into the container, and it will be consistant since (Water doesn't Compress)


This was my original SUPER SIMPLE design before I improved things. Just Single Flask Container. No rinse.
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/frozen-food-auto-feeder-3-tank-diy.737626/


Your suggestion on Splitting a single Dosing head into multiple outputs is probably more complex and costly than cheap dosing heads.
You still have to have a controller to switch the outputs and time things.
Could be Prone to leak on seals, connection points.

I use these Pump and they go on sale for $5 each.
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/330...earchweb0_0,searchweb201602_,searchweb201603_
But to run heads DIY you need a power supply, timer, etc....(which will add up quickly to $25+)

A multi head doser on aliexpress run from $38..
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/400...earchweb0_0,searchweb201602_,searchweb201603_

I've never looked into a 4 way splitter value.
Maybe they exisit.
More connection points, could clog and require more cleaning. (Possibly difficult at the Valve Pinch points)

Watch the video...It's 25% uploaded now. It will convince you to go with a Simple Doser Design when you see the efficiency and most important CLEANING STAGE.
 
Last edited:

Funston07

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 29, 2020
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
4,061
Location
Dubois
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is genius. My only question is where do you get the time to come up with something like this lol. Not to mention the trial and error portion, the fine tuning, and the write up. Nice work though
 
OP
OP
WallyB

WallyB

REEF Techno-Geek
View Badges
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
3,136
Reaction score
8,111
Location
GTA Toronto, CANADA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is genius. My only question is where do you get the time to come up with something like this lol. Not to mention the trial and error portion, the fine tuning, and the write up. Nice work though
Thanks for the Compilment.
This Feeder was super simple and a few hours to design a build after prototype. Yeah the write up was PAINFUL.

I find the time since I don't waste time on TV shows. I really want to finish Game of Throne since I started a few years ago (got to Season 5 2nd Last episode...but stalled on the Binge watching). Please don't spoil what's coming...

I also find time by building automation for my Tanks (so less tank work)......Like a DIY AUto Water changer. All 4 tanks.

You want complex and time consuming. This DIY ALK monitor (3 tank) took over 6 months, and works like a charm.
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/★-diy-auto-★-alkalinity-monitor-★-3-tank-hanna-with-raspberry-pi-ardiuno-with-advanced-features.689106/
 
Last edited:

Dom

Full Time Reef Keeper
View Badges
Joined
Apr 29, 2016
Messages
6,449
Reaction score
6,945
Location
NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Interesting Altenative design. I really appreciate your inovative creativity. Certainly may be cheaper.

I can see where you have run into consistancy issues.
Running Pressure changes with each line taking different paths.
Air volume increases (As container empties) so it takes more pressure to compress the air and then push the heavier liquid/food-soup.
You could take your design (as is). Replace the Air Pump with a Dosing Pump. Seal your container but fill it full of water.
Then pump water into the container, and it will be consistant since (Water doesn't Compress)


This was my original SUPER SIMPLE design before I improved things. Just Single Flask Container. No rinse.
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/frozen-food-auto-feeder-3-tank-diy.737626/


Your suggestion on Splitting a single Dosing head into multiple outputs is probably more complex and costly than cheap dosing heads.
You still have to have a controller to switch the outputs and time things.
Could be Prone to leak on seals, connection points.

I use these Pump and they go on sale for $5 each.
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/330...earchweb0_0,searchweb201602_,searchweb201603_
But to run heads DIY you need a power supply, timer, etc....(which will add up quickly to $25+)

A multi head doser on aliexpress run from $38..
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/400...earchweb0_0,searchweb201602_,searchweb201603_

I've never looked into a 4 way splitter value.
Maybe they exisit.
More connection points, could clog and require more cleaning. (Possibly difficult at the Valve Pinch points)

Watch the video...It's 25% uploaded now. It will convince you to go with a Simple Doser Design when you see the efficiency and most important CLEANING STAGE.

Yes... splitting the output has its limitations. Every tank would have to get fed the same number of times per day and the same amounts. Your system is better as it allows you to customize based on the needs of individual tanks.

Did I understand the link you provided correctly... do you actually feed into the return chamber and have you pump too the feeding?

I can see how substituting fluid for air in my design would be an improvement. But my design doesn't include a method to stir the contents, which would be necessary as the food would settle to the bottom.
 

HAVE YOU EVER KEPT A RARE/UNCOMMON FISH, CORAL, OR INVERT? SHOW IT OFF IN THE THREAD!

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top