Deciding between Red Sea Max e 170 and Red Sea Reefer XL 200. Which would you select as your first reef tank?

[BoxInSox]

My hours of research and video watching has led me to these two tanks as my first mixed reef tank set up.

If you experienced reefers were just getting started, and knowing what you know now, would you go for the AIO (e170) or full reef setup (XL 200 G2).

In either scenario I would likely start with the basic filtration set ups and upgrade over time. If I ultimately think I’ll go full sump, XL 200 has to be the no brainer, right?

Both seem ready to run out of the box for full cycling start up, (save main pump on XL 200) giving me some time to upgrade and stay engaged during the long initial cycle.

but like I said, I’m new to all of this, so wanted to turn to you experienced folks ti Make sure I’m not overlooking anything!

 

[PeterC99]

Welcome to R2R!

More options with the sump.

Here was my RSR 170 with sump. My wife was happy that I could keep all the equipment out of sight.

 

[Aaronjsdad]

Nice tank!

 

[PeterC99]

What did you decide on?

 

[Naturalreef]

It’s a tough choice. E-170 is nice because it’s a AIO with room for all your electronics underneath. It also allows for upgrade to a sump later on.

XL200 is bigger with nice dimensions and sump to hide all your gear.

I‘m thinking sump